I think it’s only logical to question McVay after a game like this. My question is this: is McVay a mediocre head coach, a bad play caller or both? Hear me out before you get all up in arms:
His play calling is shit at times. Square peg in a round hole and he just won’t adjust until it’s too late, if at all. You don’t go up against a physical defense like the Titans or today’s Niners the same way you go up against a bottom feeder like Houston. But McVay does, he calls the same game regardless of the opponent. That’s NOT indicative of a good coordinator, it’s arrogant if you ask me. When it works, it works. When it doesn’t, it REALLY doesn’t. Our offensive philosophy seems to be pass like hell, for better or worse. Down by 14 or up by 14, no patience in the run game. It blows my mind how, short of a few splash plays, our run game is so anemic.
For him as a head coach. Do I believe he’s a good leader of men? Yes I do. But some of his decisions as a HEAD COACH are head scratching. Allowing some of his staff go for lateral moves instead of promoting them. Hiring Morris as DC during your Super Bowl window. Continuing to play offensive coordinator while your team needs your attention elsewhere (defense, special teams?). Drafting Tutu Atwell with your only premium pick when there are actual needs elsewhere. All of these are decisions he’s making as a head coach that make me scratch my head.
I don’t think there’s a guy I’d rather have on the open market right now. But I think that McVay needs to do some serious soul searching and figure out what’s important. Whatever he’s been doing has been good, just not good enough to bring us a Lombardi and I think we can all agree is the end goal.