I'm not going to be popular for saying this, but here goes. When a ship in the navy runs aground, the guy who takes the blame is the guy in charge, the captain. This is the second week in a row we've lost a winnable game, and as much as I hate to say it, it comes down to the guy in charge. This loss is, for the second week in a row, on McVay. We could be heading into our bye at 3-2 or 2-3, but instead we are going in at 1-4 and our season is hanging by the skin of its teeth. I probably wouldn't feel like this if this undermanned team was losing games to powerhouse teams, but that's not what's happening right now. We are losing games to beatable opponents.
Are we injured? Yes. I'm not buying that as the reasons for losing this week or last, because in both of those games, we had enough talent on the field to win. In the first half of today's game, we moved the ball just fine, up and down the field. Our backups on the OL who have been forced into action have seemed to settle in and are doing a decent enough job (this is not 2022). Our D played well enough in the first half of this game (and in fact, were the only reason we went into halftime with a lead). Our red zone woes continue, and these have plagued McVay for most of his career going back to his OC days at Washington, save for a season here or there. Today we had another trip where we came away with absolutely nothing largely due to his decision making. In general, it just seems like he does not know how to go with the flow of a game and adjust his playcalling accordingly. He has his mind set on what he wants to do and stubbornly holds onto that instead of adjusting on the fly.
As for the D, I want to give him the benefit of the doubt, but it's hard. Yes, we lost the best defensive player ever due to retirement in the offseason, but we still had a solid guy in the middle ... until we traded him away. Was there more going on behind the scenes that we don't know about? Perhaps. That makes the trade a little hard to evaluate. What's not hard to evaluate is the result of the plan they had for filling in the space left by EJ, and that plan has left a gaping hole in the middle of our D that we couldn't afford after losing Donald. And unlike Donald, EJ was replaceable. Good, but replaceable. And instead we have a guy like Reeder who tries hard but is athletically limited and a guy like Rozenboom who looks more suited to being the lead guitarist of a speed metal band than an NFL ILB. We hear that Speights my not know the scheme well enough to play, but that only looks worse if Rozenboom does know the scheme and is still this fucking bad. Is it worse to have a guy in there who is athletically superior in every way but is still getting up to speed on the scheme vs. someone who knows it and still can't do what is expected of him?
No, I don't know everything and I sure as shit don't know anywhere close to as much as he does. But I can see results, and this is a results-oriented business. 1-4 on the heels of losing two very winnable games are not the results we should be getting
Now don't get me wrong, I'm not saying McVay needs to be fired. He's still a helluva coach and a great culture builder - best the Rams have ever had in my decades of fandom that stretches back to the early 1970's. But god dammit, he needs to take a good, hard look, in the mirror and address some deficiencies he has if he ever wants to get back to win another Super Bowl.
He has to stop letting his teams lose winnable games like this week and last week. This bye week needs to see some serious introspection on his part.