- Joined
- Feb 9, 2014
- Messages
- 20,922
- Name
- Peter
Just imagine if we had a kicker last game. The offense wouldn’t have went for it twice in he redzone. That puts us at 40 points. Probably 43 since Goff most likely doesn’t make that throw to Cooks that was picked. In Goffs mind, it was either get a first down or turnover on downs. Also, if Jones doesn’t knock that ball to a wide open Cooks that’s 4 more.
Of course, this is playing the “what if” game. But we could have scored 50 on Sunday with a kicker.
No doubt. It’s pretty amazing to me what we find to complain about after destroying the first two opponents. Remember when we had real problems like wondering who our QB was going to be next week? Shaun Hill vs Austin Davis? We’ve come a long way.Yeah that touchdown and 2 pt conversion right at the half would likely have been a field goal though, so subtract 5 points, plus 2 more points for the other 2 point conversions which would have been normal PATs.
As you say, it's a what if game.
That was a weird one. kinda just ran out. and whats up with the one question about product of the system. That is not what McVay said. reporter was trying to bait him.
Had they had a kicker, they would have kicked 3 XP instead of 3 2PT conversions, that makes 31 points. +2 FG, 37 points. Just sayinJust imagine if we had a kicker last game. The offense wouldn’t have went for it twice in he redzone. That puts us at 40 points. Probably 43 since Goff most likely doesn’t make that throw to Cooks that was picked. In Goffs mind, it was either get a first down or turnover on downs. Also, if Jones doesn’t knock that ball to a wide open Cooks that’s 4 more.
Of course, this is playing the “what if” game. But we could have scored 50 on Sunday with a kicker.
Eli? Because his team won a couple Superbowls? Those games were by definition "team wins". Sorry but Eli has never been HOF worthy.Aaron Rodgers is a HOF if he never plays another down...
Eli Manning & Roethlisberger are HOF, no doubt. Probably Rivers too
Iirc those are the only years he won a post season game as well.Eli? Because his team won a couple Superbowls? Those games were by definition "team wins". Sorry but Eli has never been HOF worthy.
2 Superwbowl MVP with 2 game winning drives. #6 in career yards. #8 in career TDEli? Because his team won a couple Superbowls? Those games were by definition "team wins". Sorry but Eli has never been HOF worthy.
He may get in on stats. He's just simply not worthy IMO. I have nothing against the Giants so it has nothing to do with some sort of hate going on. He just has always looked and played mediocre.2 Superwbowl MVP with 2 game winning drives. #6 in career yards. #8 in career TD
Yup. That’s HOF
Its got nothing to do with his last name. He has 2 Superbowl MVP and is 8th all time in TD and 6th in all time yards.If Eli's last name wasn't Manning, I don't think too many folks, other than some Giants fans, maybe, would consider him HOF-worthy. He had 2 good post-season runs, but wasn't the reason the Giants won those SBs. The rest of his career he's been mediocre to somewhat above average, at best. Just racking up yardage due to longevity shouldn't be enough to get into the HOF. He still might get in though, and his last name won't hurt him any.
And yet, Marino isn't... go figger.2 Superwbowl MVP with 2 game winning drives. #6 in career yards. #8 in career TD
Yup. That’s HOF
Marino is in the HOF, first Ballot HOF, or am I misunderstanding your point?And yet, Marino isn't... go figger.
HOF worth... Elite... Franchise... oh, the opinions!!![]()