fearsomefour
Legend
- Joined
- Jan 15, 2013
- Messages
- 18,432
Well he has character issues but at least there are health concerns.
Hey guys, signed up to give a first-hand take. The reason interest in Greg Reid picked up was due to FSU's Pro Day last week, where several scouts pegged him as the best corner there (over L. Joyner and T. Brooks). He was coming off a year of rehab and no team had seen him live yet. Last week was the first time with over 70 scouts and a half-dozen head coaches in attendance in Tallahassee.
I watched Reid from HS throughout college, and attended FSU while he was there. Greg has a competitive fire that is contagious to teammates and fans, and definitely has the swagger of a prize fighter. Pre-injury speaking, Reid (affectionately known as G5) was absolutely electric as a punt returner. Electric. So-so as a cornerback (again, based on 2012 play), but a dynamite return man. If he makes the 53-man squad it will most likely be as a punt return specialist and situational nickel-corner. Watch him return punts and you will see true fearlessness, as he has the pure instincts necessary to know when to field it or let it go, how to make the first guy miss, and where to run after that. He made huge returns when games were in the balance, and saved us literally hundreds of yards in field position by catching punts on the bounce or while running full speed to fair catch it before it bounces another 20 yards. That dependency alone is worthy of a job in the NFL, but his elite quickness (even for the NFL) allows him to pick up yardage on nearly every return, even when surrounded. He's gifted, a natural, any word you can conjure up where the perfect mental makeup meets the perfect tools necessary to succeed.
As a cornerback - it's a mixed bag. He's undersized and lacks the top end speed to hang with deep threats (4.5ish speed). But his quickness, ball skills, and instincts makes him a natural Nickel corner tasked with mirroring the slot. In run support he has a tendency to go for the big hit and not wrap up. In my opinion, it's his "Go Big or Go Home" mindset that causes this, and it shows with either a missed tackle or a forced fumble off a monster hit (See Marcus Lattimore @ the Chick-fil-a Bowl).
As a person, he was booted from FSU for multiple weed violations. He then tore his ACL and went undrafted. He basically hit rock bottom and finally realized he could do still live his dream if he straightened out and worked hard. All evidence points to him doing just that. He was and still is an FSU fan favorite. I hope this sheds some light on who G5 can be for the Rams, and I'll answer any questions if I can.
Thanks for the info RX!!! Few questions for you.
1. Do you think he has starter potential eventually? Or is he just going to be good depth when it comes to CB?
2. Is he good at kick returns? We already have Tavon Austin who is an awesome punt returner(when there isn't a penalty or someone in his way on his own team).
3. Can he become more sound and complete as a cb, or will he always be a "go big or go home" type?
Thanks again for all the info man, really great of you.
1. I think this greatly depends on how he has prepared in the last 18 months and his current mindset. He looked great at the pro day (you can watch it on ESPN3), but he didn't need to tackle or read patterns - only drills. I think his physical limitations will prevent him from being an every down player, despite his skills. In a year or 2 with better strength and willingness to improve his tackling, however, he could definitely become a starter in the Nickel package once he gets the defensive scheme down.
2. This was always a point of debate in his college years at FSU. Due to his lack of straight-line speed, any time he breaks into the open field he will be caught. The best he can do is get you to the opposing 30-40 yard line, I doubt he will ever take a kickoff for a touchdown. But his ability to make guys miss and find the open hole definitely allowed him to be better than average. It just depends on if you want better than average with no chance at a TD, or give another guy with less vision a shot who could go all the way if he gets free. Personally I see a lot of similarities between Tavon and Reid, but Reid lacks the top gear. G5 may have better vision, but that will have to be seen on the field.
3. I think this is answered similarly to question #1. If he has dedicated himself to becoming an NFL caliber player, he has the tools to succeed. He struggled with playing assignments early in his career, so the coaches basically made him a roving freelance player who played from instinct and he became an All-American caliber player that single-handedly changed games (hence the Go Big attitude). FSU's head coach Jimbo Fisher has said for years Greg was the best "football player" he'd ever coached...not the biggest/strongest/fastest but that he possessed the innate ability to know where the ball was going and react before anyone else. He will never overcome his height and top-end speed. Has he overcome his inability to play within a scheme? That is the big question IMO that will decide if he can become an every down player.
How in the heck does anyone get thrown off the FSU team
It's what the ones who don't get thrown off the team are doing that worries me.
Thanks for the feedback again.
1. Well since our greatest need at CB is at nickle, he seems like a good prospect for us.
2. I much rather have a guy who can get us to the 30 or 40 yard line than a guy who usually gets to the 20 at best with a return or two a year. Starting at the 30-40 yard line islas great starting position and trumps the 20 yarder with a "chance" to return one.
3. So basically he has great instincts? Not the best size or speed or anything. Like you said, a lot will depend on if he can learn and fit into a scheme.
Do you think he would be better as a nickle cb or a hybrid fs/cb role? I am looking more for the rams a solitary nickle cb role, someone who can fill in for finnigans roll before he went down hill.
In honesty, he sounds like a guy who might not be the most physically gifted, but has good instincts and plays bigger than his side and if he can adapt to a specific scheme, could be a great player. That last part being the most important, if he can adapt to that, seems like he could fit in the nfl in a starting role eventually.
Which ones are those? I mean from FSU, I am not up to date on the problems they have so actually am curious.
All this guy is a early UDFA signing. At his peak a couple years ago before he tore his ACL he was at best a late round pick or more likely a UDFA. He's too small to play safety, and is even small for a nickle.
Let him come to camp and compete. You never know with a year on the PS he might be ready. I just don't see him pushing Tru or JJ day one of camp.
Welcome to the ROD Rx!RxNoleRx dipping his left foot into clam infested waters:
Saying stuff.
One might hope that Snead & Fisher have been looking very hard @ #20 Joyner and saw & discovered a bunch on #5 Reid during this review. Fisher has a #20 vacant now with vet Darian Stewart departed. The number #5 is also vacant. I would love to see both Joyner & Reid on this 2014 Ram team. We are half way there now.