What happened with the 49ers and Vic Fangio? Why won't Shanahan call outside runs for Trey Lance? And other questions and answers.
theathletic.com
Kyle is almost borderline hostile when he talks about Jimmy G. Frankly it seems weird, especially considering how much the Niners win with him at QB. What’s his beef with No. 10? — Joshua L.
There’s no doubt, even among Shanahan’s other short and sharp answers in that presser, his brisk shutdown of “any scenario” that could lead to Garoppolo returning to the 49ers this offseason was an attention-getter. And to me, the fact that Lynch didn’t immediately jump in with a more diplomatic response only underlined the possibility that something had gone a bit askew in this long and complicated saga.
Garoppolo won 42 combined regular-season (38-17 record) and postseason (4-2) games for the 49ers. He could’ve been a Super Bowl MVP if he’d made one or two more plays a few years ago. He’s always been a very popular figure in the locker room. It wasn’t wrong to expect something a little warmer from the 49ers’ brass for Garoppolo’s franchise exit, right?
Well, I checked around the team and discovered:
Yes, the relationship between Garoppolo and Shanahan/Lynch seems to have gone a bit south in the days or weeks leading up to the NFC Championship Game loss in Philadelphia. I don’t know if there was a specific blow-up or conversation that led to this. I don’t know what the main issue was. We know that Garoppolo won a lot of games in his six seasons with the 49ers and partially bailed them out this season by agreeing to come back after believing he was going to get traded or cut last offseason.
If I was to make a knowledgeable guess, I’d say that the mood was always a little questionable this season between Garoppolo and Shanahan. They’ve never been especially close, even while they were winning. But they worked very well together for long stretches over this period. The personality differences were part of why this worked. Until Garoppolo got hurt. Then hurt again. Then hurt again. And in between all that, Shanahan and Lynch traded a ton of stuff to move up to acquire his replacement, Trey Lance. And even after Garoppolo jumped back in after Lance was hurt this season, Shanahan daydreamed about Brock Purdy playing one day and then Garoppolo got hurt again and Purdy did play quite well.
Finally, Shanahan and Lynch decided to keep Garoppolo on the active roster all through December and January after his injury, hoping (believing?) he could come back from his foot injury at some point during the playoffs to provide insurance in case of a Purdy injury. They could’ve used that roster spot for somebody else, maybe defensive tackle Hassan Ridgeway. But Shanahan and Lynch saved it for Garoppolo, who tried and couldn’t get healthy enough to be Purdy’s backup in the conference title game. And then Purdy got hurt.
Again, I don’t know that any of this directly led to Shanahan’s abrupt answer about Garoppolo and, before that, Garoppolo bypassing the media during locker-room clean-out day last week, but I imagine this was part of the atmosphere around the two.
Which maybe is the perfect weird way to end the extended high/low Garoppolo era with the 49ers. There was no chance Garoppolo was sticking around again as the 49ers’ backup in 2023, and there was also no chance that Shanahan or Lynch would’ve wanted him to once Purdy emerged as a quality starter. Shanahan’s terse answer was just the official notification of this.