- Joined
- Jan 14, 2013
- Messages
- 5,427
- Name
- Dave
What's funny is people who put their opinions out there are called out for having the audacity to do it. None of us think we're infallible but we have opinions and have no problem voicing them. I have never claimed to be perfect or an NFL GM or coach of any kind. But last I checked I can still have opinions on what this club I and everybody else here has devoted a lot of time and emotion into. I won't ever apologize for having an opinion or sharing it. People can passive aggressively attack us and that's fine. They can lie and say things like we all hated Cam Akers last year which is just plain false. Most of us thought there were better picks at that spot the team could use. We all recognized he was talented and used to running behind a bad line. We probably questioned why spend a 3rd round pick the year before to only spend a 2nd on Akers, wondering what it meant for Henderson. It's all good in the end. I'm happy to admit when I was wrong just like you and those others of us that put our opinions out for people to read.
What's funny is people who put their opinions out there are called out for having the audacity to do it. None of us think we're infallible but we have opinions and have no problem voicing them. I have never claimed to be perfect or an NFL GM or coach of any kind. But last I checked I can still have opinions on what this club I and everybody else here has devoted a lot of time and emotion into. I won't ever apologize for having an opinion or sharing it. People can passive aggressively attack us and that's fine. They can lie and say things like we all hated Cam Akers last year which is just plain false. Most of us thought there were better picks at that spot the team could use. We all recognized he was talented and used to running behind a bad line. We probably questioned why spend a 3rd round pick the year before to only spend a 2nd on Akers, wondering what it meant for Henderson. It's all good in the end. I'm happy to admit when I was wrong just like you and those others of us that put our opinions out for people to read.
I want to say something here, because I have mentioned both last year's reaction to Akers and I have mentioned being turned off by (what I see as) over-the-top negative reactions and so I want to make sure to clarify my point of view.
For me personally, I know not everyone hated the Akers pick or didn't like the player - but it's not a lie that the initial response to his selection was met with plenty of smug dissatisfaction. I know because he was my favorite pick and while I was stoked, the general consensus was "bad value" or something like that...
I have been consistently concerned about this regimes O-line since Saffold left. I have wanted above all else to strengthen our line into an elite unit. I wasn't sold on Edward's, Evans and was not that high on Noteboom either going into last offseason. Some posters here were adamant that our line was in good shape going forward, I shouldn't worry. Then last season I watched as weakness in our interior line and lack of explosive speed outside combined to force McVay (and Goff) to essentially give up on the deep option. Goff played a role in this too, but it was a team problem, not just a QB problem.
I share many of the popular opinions about what we need or what the concerns are.... but under McVay, there has been method to most of what feels like madness to us fans.
I know you know this - everyone knows this- but the NFL isn't about winning the draft. Evaluating and mocking drafts is a fun exercise but it stops being fun when fans lose their shit because the professionals didn't do what the amateurs thought they should/would, whatever.
Fans risk nothing. Our projections and expectations are formed with a fraction of the information the pros have...
I like that Snead and McVay have a plan that goes deeper than "biggest needs + top rated player available at that position = who we should draft."
That kind of strategy will work sometimes but it's also how you end up missing on Jason Smith and Greg Robinson and you've flushed the 2nd pick in the draft down the toilet twice in a few short years and you still don't have a LT.
There are some very knowledgeable fans here. People who have proven to have a great feel for drafts and prospects and they make this site great too. That's where I stand on that.