Obviously, My opinion is in the minority here. Shaun Hill IS the better QB, and while Davis has played better than anything I would have ever imagined based on what I have seen in THREE training camps, let's not forget that throwing 3 INTs in 10 quarters is never going to sit well with a Fisher coached team.
For those who seem to think he has played so well... He has missed on plenty of throws that an NFL QB has to make. There were plenty of throws in yesterdays game (two to Britt) that were just plain and simple bad throws. The first one was the overthrow down the sideline, where he simply had to put some air under the ball, and Britt pulls away from the CB. The second was the skinny post route where Britt had to dive for the ball. That pass has to be completed.
On the pick 6, he simply made a bad read. Watch the play again, and see Quick get inside the CB on a post route. Pressure or no pressure, if Davis sees Quick make the break at the time he made it, (prior to the throw to Stacy), its a TD. And for those who want to dismiss the last INT as one that doesn't count, it was a bad decision, and even worse throw.
Like I said, he has played a whole lot better than I imagined he would. But I am not ready to overlook the obvious mistakes he makes because he is "fun to watch" or "plays with fire". Bottom line, he has thrown TWO pick six INT's in 2 1/2 games. This team needs him to be consistent, not necessarily a gunslinger.
For me, it doesn't matter if its Hill, Davis or even Bradford, when this team throws the ball 42 times in ANY game, it is not a good thing.
