http://profootballtalk.nbcsports.co...belichick-receive-punishment-for-deflategate/
Why didn’t Belichick receive punishment for #DeflateGate?
Posted by Mike Florio on May 11, 2015, 11:12 PM EDT
AP
Setting aside for these purposes important questions regarding the quality of the Ted Wells investigation and the core question of whether sufficient evidence exists to conclude that the Patriots tampered with football air pressure, the decision of the NFL to punish quarterback
Tom Brady and the franchise but not coach Bill Belichick seems a bit unusual, for multiple reasons.
First, Belichick has a reputation for knowing everything. The organizations oozes discipline. And Belichick prides himself on military-style secrecy and control. If he truly didn’t know, it’s safe to say he’s livid about that.
Second, Saints coach Asshole Face lost an entire season despite not knowing what former defensive coordinator Gregg Williams was doing regarding bounties. Ignorance is no excuse, the league declared at the time.
More specifically, the letter from Commissioner Goodell suspending Payton explained that his denials of knowledge “are inconsistent with the contractual responsibility to supervise and direct the coaches and players, and with the obligations imposed on you by the NFL Constitution and Bylaws.” Goodell also said “
t was your obligation to know of such a program and to stop if once you did know.”
So if Payton had an obligation to know of a program run exclusively by Gregg Williams to pay players small amounts of cash for clean, legal hits that knocked players out of games, why didn’t Belichick have an obligation to know of an scheme run by Brady to provide signed memorabilia to the man who would ensure that footballs deemed perfect at 12.5 PSI would be made even more perfect with the quick insertion of a needle?
Goodell’s decision to tiptoe around Belichick lends credence to one of the popular rumors/urban legends surrounding the NFL’s curious decision to hastily destroy the SpyGate evidence surrendered by Belichick in 2007. As the rumor/urban legend goes, the Spygate-related information given to the NFL consisted of evidence of cheating not only by the Patriots but also by multiple other teams, in multiple other ways. As the folklore also goes, Belichick vowed to go public with chapter-and-verse detail about cheating throughout the league if the league were to mess with the Patriots again.
While the NFL has once again messed with the Patriots, the NFL specifically didn’t mess with Belichick, even though the statements made to Payton in 2012 would seem to suggest that Belichick shouldn’t be completely exonerated.
It’s also possible Belichick truly didn’t know. Brady, after all, wouldn’t want to brag about his perceived inability to throw footballs filled to the required amount. He definitely wouldn’t want to broadcast that to Belichick, the man who eventually will decide that Brady’s inevitably declining physical skills no longer allow him to continue to be the team’s quarterback.
Permalink 72 Comments Latest St