I focus on line play all of the time. Noteboom has never been a stud. Consider how many teams would trade their actual stud OLTs for Noteboom. He’s bottom of the league.
He can’t handle bull rushes. He doesn’t play strong. He’s all finesse, which may be why he has a good kick step. But he’s always had trouble playing with strength. His second level blocking in space has improved but again not to what I’d call stud level.
Maybe what you are seeing isn’t that Kromer improved the play of those players, but that he just had them playing better than Carberry did. The only guy that really impressed me under Kromer was Edwards. He looked like a future All Pro for a season and a half. Carberry may not be that good of an Oline coach.
And the comment about the line being in a Super Bowl is meaningless. Carberry’s line went to one too. Plus both had Whitworth’s play and leadership. If making it to a Super Bowl was a testament to the greatness of an Oline coach then neither Kromer, nor Carberry wouldn’t have been fired.
So you focus on the O line play all the time? That's gotta be hard to do and still watch the action. I re-watched and focused on one player in question. I'd think that really gives the best perspective. We just disagree.
But the fact they made it to the Superbowl is important. The 2 years we went to the Superbowl the common denominators were Whitworth and Havenstein. But ironically the biggest factor was the starting 5 started 80 games each year. It reflected in the QBs numbers, despite there being 2 different QBs. Sack% allowed was 5.5% (2018) and 4.9% (2021). Yards per attempt were 8.3 (2018) and 8.1 (2021). Yards per reception were 12.9 (2018) and 12.1 (2021). TDs to Ints was 2.7 (2018) and 2.3 (2021). Hell, 2018 Goff looked
almost as good as 2021 Stafford. Wny? Because of O line health, talent and continuity.
We'll see what happens with Noteboom but my guess is he's on the squad starting at LT.
"He can't handle bull rushes"? Give some examples. Instead of just saying "he can't handle bull rushes" tell us how many times the bull rush has beat him. For instance, after I watched and charted the first 5 games this year, I pointed out Nick Bosa lined up opposite JN 37 times. Want to guess how many times Bosa "won"? Or better yet, you tell me. Tell me how many times he beat JN with a bull rush.
"He doesn't play strong"? What TF does that mean? He looked pretty strong to me punching Bosa, Parsons and others off their rush. Is that a Kiper term?
"He's all finesse, which may be why he has a good kick step"? So you agree he has a good kick step but you attribute that to finesse? He's got a good kick step because he's physically talented and has excellent balance. Add to that a strong punch, very good downfield vision and blocking and you have what some might call, a stud LT,
But the company line is "he sucks". Like I said, we'll just disagree.