Here's the question in my mind: how much longer will Whitworth be able to beat father time? I mean, after all, father time is undefeated. I dont want to get rid of Noteboom or Havenstein because what happens when you do and the Whitworth gets hurt again or falls off the cliff mid-season. Now you have no good depth at OT. These days it takes a year or two for any really good Olineman to really come into their own due to the schemes ran at the collegiate level. Thats with top picks. Might a top pick guy come in and produce right off the bat? Yes, but he isn't going to be havenstein or even Noteboom probably for the 1st year. Solid, not great. Not the Noteboom is great...yet.
In my mind, protecting Jared Goff and allowing him to flourish is priority #1 from here on out. I dont care what anyone says, dude is legit talented. Aaron Rodgers, for all his talent, has been on the outside looking in for years. Conversation had begun about how great he really even was and if he was declining early. Now he has an elite Oline and look at him. Jared Goff isn't even 27 years old for crying out loud.
Oh, that brings up another great point. The Packers oline and the importance of depth. Baktieri (sp?), his truly elite LT is out for the season. That line hasn't even skipped a beat. Imagine a sub-par tackle against Floyd in that playoff game. Maybe it goes a little differently.
That brings up another point. Let Floyd go. I mean, try to retain him ofc, just not to the detriment of other positions. Who tf was Floyd before AD? Was Floyd a factor against high level oline with AD hurt? No he wasn't. Floyd is not a guy who excells without someone else present to be a difference maker. Floyd is a piece of the puzzle, not a cog. Puzzle pieces are replaceable. I dont think you pay a puzzle piece 14+ mil/year. You plug another dude in who can do the same stuff. You build around your cogs. AD, Ramsey, Goff. Those are the guys that you support. It just so happens that Goffs play is directly impacted by every single person on the O, more so than any other position. To me, the choice is obvious. I find another + edge type for cheap and retain JJ. Make him a cog. Allow the draft to maintain the amazing safety/secondary depth. If you can't retain JJ, let him and Floyd walk, back fill safety with the current roster/draft, find another + edge type for cheap, go after a Center.
Anyways. Thats my take. It may be unpopular, im sorry if it is. I respect yalls ideas and opinions. I just happen to see it in another shade of blue.