We had to pass. Cowboys loaded up to stop the run and dared Goff to beat them. And for most of this game, he had time. When he didn't have time, he was blitzed and sometimes the D brings more than what the OL can block - it's on the QB to figure that out.
We have what, $90 million in Cooks, Gurley, Goff and Donald next year?
Gurley's poor vision is showing, along with whatever else is going on with him. Cooks is probably playing like he's playing because of the concussions - but if so, shut him down. Yes we got blown out, but if he catches that wide open first down pass when we were down 14-7, maybe we go down and score and the offense keeps us in the game a while longer. Goff is just....not close to worth the money right now.
Donald is all world but....at some point you have to ask the question: if our defense has now had three of these games where they just get destroyed (and two have come after trading Peters away), then why pay anyone on the defense that much money? Fowler has had an outstanding year but, again, if the D is going to get shredded, Saffold would have been the better option.
In hindsight, the inconsistency is easy to figure out - we got obliterated by two teams that had an advantage over us the OL and DL - the most disturbing thing about this is Aaron Donald. We can understand the OL getting eaten up by the Ravens, Cowboys, Niners, etc. But the DL with Donald should be able to handle any offensive line. And if it can't, again, why pay him? It's inevitably going to mean you end up starting marginal players next to him, which is clearly not working.
This team is fully structured to play from in front - which means that we need to do whatever - and I mean whatever - it takes to field an elite offensive line next year. Our most tradeable assets are going to be Kupp, Woods, Donald and John Johnson - option number one of course will be to cut Matthews and Weddle to free up space to sign some free agents - but elite offensive linemen don't usually hit FA. So if that fails, we need to sacrifice one or two of the guys above to field that elite OL. Because without it, Goff is a blackhole on this roster.
I'd much rather field Cooks/Reynolds/Kupp or Cooks/Reynolds/Woods with a good OL than having our elite WR group intact but continue to fail because of a mediocre to bad OL.