It’s not like the offense is complete yet. They can still improve in certain areas.
That's absolutely true, but we had arguably the best HB in the NFL last year. HB play isn't really an area where we need improvement. It would be nice to have a good backup, but that's why we have rookie contracts. I'd love to see the offense improve, but I think those improvements need to come at TE. I expect they will with Everett next year.
McVay wants to have the most lethal offense in the league. You could tell that game against the Falcons hurt him. A guy like Lewis would have really helped bring the offense up a notch.
How? Gurley was running wild on the ground, but he was being smothered in the passing game. How would Lewis fare any better? We certainly weren't going to take Gurley off the field for Lewis.
Here's a damning fact, Malcolm Brown had a total of 6 carries and 5 receptions in games that weren't blowouts last year (not counting Week 17). We simply didn't use him in close games. We fed Gurley the rock. I see the value in having a backup HB in case Gurley gets hurt, but I don't see the value in spending big bucks on a backup who we don't want on the field.
I understand you have concerns with the defense. But we have the cap space to sign Donald, Joyner, Watkins and a couple good free agents plus our draft picks. What do we have? $53 million freed up now? I bet Barron gets cut too. Which would bring us to around $60 million. Plenty of money to bring in another piece for our offense.
No. We have around $48 million after the Quinn and Peters trades. That drops to $37 million with Joyner being tagged. And we still need to re-sign a bunch of players, add a #2 CB, replace Barron, and add a NT. If we sign Dion Lewis for $6 million per year, that means not being able to afford a starter somewhere else.
Take a look at the last 10 Super Bowl winners. Very rarely do they have a do it all, stud RB. Marshawn Lynch, Ray Rice, Rashard Mendenhall? You need multiple pieces and skill players to win the big game. We can’t put it all on Gurleys shoulders or you’ll see a repeat of what happened vs Atlanta.
Atlanta? The game where Gurley averaged over 7 yards per carry and ran for 101 yards? Our HB situation didn't lose us the Atlanta game.
Fact is that HB is one of the easiest positions to find valuable players at on Day 3 because it's devalued. We don't need to pay big money for a backup to Gurley. We can draft one. I'm not taking Gurley off the field for anyone, much less Dion Lewis. And Gurley doesn't need enough breathers for Lewis to have enough touches for it to be a good deal.
Where does that leave us? It leaves us with taking our best player off the field on 3rd downs to justify giving Lewis all that money. I really don't like it, my friend.