Garrett had like 35 sacks in 28 games. Yea it was D2. But those are the number you would expect from a D2 guy to make the NFL. I got my eye on him. He may be a sleeper for us I think.Posting from another thread:
Chatarius (I absolutely fucking refuse to call him "Tutu") Atwell: F
(Easily one of the worst picks I've seen McSnead make. I can't imagine him doing well, I'm sorry. And Bolton went right after him. They picked a gadget player at best with the second round pick, likely because they panicked when the Hags took Eskridge. If they wanted a deep threat, Darden was for the taking, and he would've been a better pick at this stage than Atwell (or, hell, pick Bolton and then Darden!). He'll have to do an absolute fuckton to win me over.)
Ernest Jones: C+
(I've admittedly warmed up to him a bit. I still think there were better players, but I'm getting a JJ3 vibe around him, so I can live with it. He's a tackling machine, a good run defender. I have concerns about his overall athleticism and if he's truly a sideline-to-sideline defender.)
Bobby Brown III: A-
(BB3 (since we no longer have a JJ3) could be an absolutely dominant defensive tackle next to Donald. He's a load to deal with in the running game, and if he learns from Donald how to use his hands and gets his conditioning straight, we could be talking about a young Haynesworth.)
Robert Rochell: A-
(Rochell is my favorite pick in this class. He reminds me a lot of Marcus Peters, only without the attitude issues that plagued Peters. He's a ballhawk, always has his hands active without getting grabby, and blankets receivers. He's big and fearless. My only question is if he fills against the run, but if Ramsey mentors him, I can't imagine it as a problem.)
Jacob Harris: B
(This kid could be a steal. Key word: could. I'm glad he got drafted as a tight end, but it's going to take a while for him to bulk up to tight end status. We may not see a payoff until year three. It's a better draft pick in the fourth than, say, a first round pick, but that's still banking on a lot for this kid. He is a sold special teams player, so that helps his grade.)
Earnest Brown IV: C+
(I can get behind this pick. EB4 needs a lot of work with core strength and learning hand usage, and that'll take at least a year or two. I don't know if he'll ever be great, but if we're talking about a solid role player, yeah, I'm sold. Still, I think we could've made a better pick here.)
Jake Funk: D
(I admire their commitment to special teams, but you can't tell me there weren't better running backs on the board, namely Jermar Jefferson, Gerrid Doaks, Kylin Hill, just to mention a few. I can't put too much faith in a running back who has had two ACLs on the same knee. And I absolutely cringe at the name puns. Just...no.)
Ben Skowronek: C
(My favorite of the seventh round picks - which isn't saying much. If he can move to tight end (an H-back), be our answer to Kyle Juszcyzk, I'll be much more on board. Right now, I see someone who's far too slow to make an impact as a wide receiver, someone who could definitely get cut and be picked up, like Clay Johnston was. I'd have honestly picked Sage Surratt, just because of potential; if you're in the seventh round, you can gamble on that kind of stuff.)
Chris Garrett: D-
(Who? Again, who? You can't tell me that this guy is a better edge rusher than Charles Snowden. He's not athletic, not big, and he produced against much lesser competition.)
Overall Grade: C-
(Better players were available, and the Atwell pick, if it doesn't work out (in my opinion, likely), could set us back a year or two.)
I completely agree with this assessment. Good post.I give it a "C".
We grabbed some players with intriguing upside, but ultimately, it seems they reached a bit on a few players while simultaneously using prime picks on positions that were already comparatively strong for this roster (WR) while completely ignoring positions of need (OL).
Even if you buy the narrative that the players we have in-house on the OL are good enough, which is certainly up for debate, this OL draft class was supposedly very deep. So if we are/were drafting for the future more so than this coming season, as some suggest, why not grab some to develop? Whitworth is getting older and a bunch of our young guys will need new contracts soon.
I am really not a fan of the Tutu pick, at least that draft position. But otherwise, I don't find myself too fussed at the draft seemingly being weak. It's impossible to predict, anyway. Let's see how these young men do! Having said that, after this showing, I don't think it is at all unreasonable to worry if losing Brad Holmes to Detroit might have hurt our drafting prowess. Time will tell.
For me this is more about grading how they filled perceived needs than grading the picks.