I would like to read the posts from prior to this year's draft and even the past several drafts concerning WHICH particular QB some of our more 'verbal' members have endorsed. I'm not singling out jrry32, BUT since he has opined for Winston as a future star QB, who in the past has jrry32 THOUGHT would be a star QB and did that prophecy come to fruition?
I searched for all of jrry32's old posts, but there are only 10 pages of posts dating only to late August so there is no way to know for certain if he has that certain 'IT' factor that can pick out a star QB better than the NFL coaching staffs in general.
All I know is that there have been posts after posts after posts for as long as I've been a member of the various football forums from supposed 'QB savants' (and I'm not including jrry32 in this observation, even though I used him as an example) who have been absolutely, positively CERTAIN that QB X or QB Y would be a Freakin' NFL STAR!! Locker, McCoy, Russell, Geno Smith, Manziel (who, I admit, may still amaze), Bridgewater, Bortles, Gabbert, Clausen, etc., etc., etc. The ONLY bona fide star -- who was prophesied as being one PRIOR to taking the field -- in the past several years , has been Andrew Luck and, perhaps, to a lesser extent, due to injuries, Bradford and Griffen. I guess Cam Newton is also a star, but then there is the epic fail of the Titan's highly-sought-after QB, whose name escapes me now. Mark Sanchez, anyone? The Mannings have been stellar, I admit, but drafting ANY QB with one's Number 1 pick is a crap shoot, pure and simple. Draft a Number 1 with character issues, no matter how talented that individual may be, and a team is just asking, no, make that BEGGING, for TROUBLE!
There are no seers with an unblemished track record when it comes to deciding who will be the NEXT BIG THING as an NFL QB.
I believe we are better off, for the time being, sticking with what we've got -- Davis -- and trying to build a decent supporting cast around him to SEE if he can develop into the real thing. I am not convinced that he is incapable of doing so. From my perspective, Davis -- who went undrafted -- has done far better than many of the more highly sought after QB prospects who WERE drafted, which only proves to me that most people -- even NFL coaches and GMs -- are as incapable of making a GOOD QB choice as I AM.