Winston. Mariota. None of them are Luck. Neither will look good with a porous line. Winston doesn't move like Luck, nor does he have the pure football acumen imo. And Mariota sure as crap isn't built like Luck. Luck is one of the few who can help overcome a pee pee poor run game and O-Line.
Draft O-line like a junkie on crack.
That's where you're wrong. Winston moves extremely well and has a ridiculously high football acumen. In fact, don't take it from me...take it from a QB Coach that worked with both:
QB guru George Whitfield believes FSU redshirt sophomore Jameis Winston's football IQ is in the same tier as Andrew Luck.
Whitfield has worked with both passers, so obviously he would not say anything negative about Winston outside of critiquing one of his plays. Winston has more success inside the pocket in terms of eye level and working through progressions than any other passer in college football. We think this statement actually has merit. We focus on judging a player by things we see on the field, and for how often Winston is called a "moron" or "dumb," he is certainly not one when playing the game.
In fact, watch the Notre Dame game. Winston struggled in the first half as he got relentlessly pounded by Notre Dame's Front 7. He came out in the 2nd half and was as dominant as I've seen in college. Notre Dame didn't change up anything they were doing. They were coming after him with blitz after blitz. His OL wasn't picking it up well. You know why Winston absolutely dominated them? HE ADJUSTED. He completely changed the way he was attacking Notre Dame and looked utterly unstoppable.
Winston has an extremely high football IQ, he has a strong arm, he is mobile, he's big, he's strong, he is a leader on the field, he is comfortable in the pocket, he throws players open, he anticipates routes, and he understands how to read a defense and go through progressions.
If the media hadn't torn the guy apart the way they did, he'd be getting hype through the roof right now. He isn't a perfect QB prospect but they don't exist. However, his combination of tools(both mental and physical) are off the charts.