Soul Surfer
Legend
- Joined
- Mar 22, 2017
- Messages
- 6,943
- Name
- Charles Mazyck
Only if he gets us to the Super Bowl.Soon to be a 2022 NFL head coach
Only if he gets us to the Super Bowl.Soon to be a 2022 NFL head coach
Well, they might actually have a 1st rounder to trade by then. HahaIf they wait another 5 years they'll be able to do it lmao
That was a fast Hire.
This is my guess why the parting of the ways was so late. McVay wanted the right guy.McVay likely had conversations with Carberry prior to letting Kromer go.
This is my guess why the parting of the ways was so late. McVay wanted the right guy.
I bet if he didn’t close the deal on one of those on his short list, Kromer is still here...
Would he take reasonable steps to ensure the team doesn't fail because he fired the O line coach and couldn't get a good replacement? Good I hope he would.If that's the case it's not only ruthless but Machiavellian behavior. Our coach wouldn't do that... would he?
Would he take reasonable steps to ensure the team doesn't fail because he fired the O line coach and couldn't get a good replacement? Good I hope he would.
Call it Machiavellian if you want, but I think that's just run of the mill good organizational planning. It's not like he engineered a situation to get Callahan fired and another to get Kromer to quit, then hired Callahan. He made sure he has a good replacement before he made a decision about paying ways with an adequate coach. And that's if he even was a part of the decision. I haven't heard any details. Maybe Kromer is just walking away.
Two years?The Good News for Carberry is he will be a Head Coach in Two years.
Would he take reasonable steps to ensure the team doesn't fail because he fired the O line coach and couldn't get a good replacement? Good I hope he would.
Call it Machiavellian if you want, but I think that's just run of the mill good organizational planning. It's not like he engineered a situation to get Callahan fired and another to get Kromer to quit, then hired Callahan. He made sure he has a good replacement before he made a decision about paying ways with an adequate coach. And that's if he even was a part of the decision. I haven't heard any details. Maybe Kromer is just walking away.
This could also be great if the Rams are looking for future Olinemen in the draft in the next few years. As a college coach he has seen players first hand and could have some connections a la Jimmy Johnson or Pete Carrol
Sorry, but if McVay delayed firing Kromer for nearly two months in order to line up his replacement-- which I highly doubt, and which makes no sense-- it was the wrong thing to do. If the organization wants to hang coaches out to dry then it will earn and deserve a poor reputation for how it treats them.
But I was responding to speculation which seems extremely unlikely to me. If McVay could hire Carberry now he could have done so in early January. The supposed behavior would also be unworthy of McVay. In the past McVay has given coaches and players timely notice if they're fired or cut so they can compete for other opportunities.
The explanation that instead makes sense is that McVay and Kromer could not agree about the path forward-- that being the subject of intense discussion only AFTER the end of the season-- either with respect to personnel, or scheme, or both.
Where have they not been good at evaluating O-line talent?That’s a excellent point, Rams have NOT BEEN good at evaluating OL talent under Les’s watch. Let’s hope this was part of the hiring equation
Where have they not been good at evaluating O-line talent?
Whitworth? Wasn't hard to evaluate a guy on his way to the HoF
Sullivan? Was good for about half a year but was destroyed in the SB. Average player.
Edwards? Has been pretty good but needed injuries to get in over a guy who'd disappointed before getting hurt twice.
Evans? Do we know what he has in him? He's been ok at times when on the field.
Corbett? Pretty good at Guard this year but what is he going forward? Personal fan of him but to say he's anything special might be a stretch at this point.
Blythe? Had a good season/half season at Guard and is not good at Center.
Noteboom? He's not a guard we don't know what he is at tackle. Has injury issues.
Anchrum? What do we have? Like the guy but we don't know yet.
Shelton? A question mark
Brewer? Question mark 2.0
After watching the debacle of Fisher/Boudreau?
I would give Snead and McVay a solid A leaning towards an A+.
The only players they've picked that I don't particularly like are Brian Allen and Jamil Demby and they're actually still on the roster.
Interesting to see who the pair him with the new Assistant OL Coach, might be a former player, somewhat fiery, I know they had interviewed Giants Assistant OL Coach Ben Wilkerson, but that might have been for Kromer as worked with him in Chicago.
Hahahahahahahha!! You're just finding a cheap excuse to have a problem! It was sarcasm.
I'm always an optimist when it comes to the rams... but the thing that's cringe-worthy to me is the attitude that we can have all this turnover, lose key players, our entire coaching staff, our only good OL is 64 years old and not every hire will be an upgrade - but we should all act like it because McVay + Stafford.
I guarantee I'm not the only one here noticing some hypocrisy lately.
I believe in McVay and think Stafford offers an upgrade for a few years... but I don't subscribe to this instant contender fantasy.
Sorry that makes you supposedly cringe. I guess if you're trying to have a problem, it's easy to find one.
His biggest hit was with veterans. His developee list here isn't all that impressive. To date we've thrown shade at Snead on that but maybe Kromes got the guys he wanted. I do think a lot of Edwards but Evans was quite shaky, Boom is a pipe dream, Blythe is a backup, and don't get me started on Demby.
I think highly of Kromer. But there is some room to question his track record it's got some spotty to it.