I've been willing to give Fisher a little bit of leash with Keenum as long as we were a) winning and b) Keenum wasn't hurting the team. But today is the kind of day where you have to pull the leash in fully, because while you can't pin the loss on one player, you can say one player contributed disproportionately to it, and that player was none other than Case Keenum.
First, I'll acknowledge he made some good throws today, and we were able to pick up yards in big chunks through the airs (and as an aside, our much-maligned WR corps is actually playing some pretty decent football these days). His stat line was good. But it's the throws he didn't make - huge ones - that made a crucial difference in this game.
First of all, on the pick six, the throw was simply inexcusable. He had a very clean pocket, no pressure at all. So nobody can say it was rushed. Second, the DB had very tight coverage. Simply put, there was nowhere to go with that ball given the way that route is supposed to be thrown. He would have been better off just sailing it over Cooper's head for an incompletion. There are QB's with much better arms than Keenum that would have not been able to complete the pass in that particular situation. That was the pivotal play of the game, it completely shifted momentum to the Bills and put us in a hole. You can't blame anyone else when he has good protection and thus has time to look elsewhere when the receiver is covered that closely. That one is all on Keenum there.
There are also two potential TD's missed, to Quick and to Tavon. Those throws have to be made. If they are made, the Rams get up big early. Again, he had good protection on those plays, and his receivers were open. He just didn't make the throws. So that's two potentially positive game changing plays he didn't make, and then there is the game-changing negative play of the pick six. Throw in his failure to even try to go to a wide open Quick on a crucial third down play and there's another positive play not made. We've got a guy sitting on the bench with the arm to make those positive plays that Keenum missed, we should use him.
Add to that, it seems like at least half the sacks Keenum takes come from holding onto the ball for too long. Irrespective of what you think of our OL, even the best ones won't be able to block forever. The QB has to get rid of the ball, or get the hell out of there and take off running to make some positive yardage.
As for the OL, I can understand the frustration, particularly in the running game. But something about the blocking scheme just seems off, because none of them look particularly good. Saffold has, in the past, looked stellar at G, Havenstein looked good as a rookie last year, and GRob was improving. But neither of the former two looked particularly good in the last two games and the latter has gone backwards after seemingly going forward for a while. Before today's game, I re-watched every offensive snap of the Cardinals game last week. Particularly on running plays, it's hard to tell sometimes whose assignment is whose, and it looks like the guys in charge of executing those assignments feel the same way. I don't remember this being a problem last year, and I can't remember if they were using a zone blocking scheme as they are this year. But I'm really beginning to have my doubts as to whether what they are trying to do this year plays into the strength of the players we have. I'm not sure how much of that is on Boudreau and how much on Boras, but ultimately the buck stops with the latter.
As for Fisher's call on the fake punt, it's one of those things where you're a genius with huge balls if it's successful and an idiot if it's not. That being said, I don't think it was the time and place to go for it given that the defense, after settling down, had only given up a field goal since the early 2nd quarter. Putting a guy in motion on a punt play is pretty stupid too. And third ... look, I get the Bradley Marquez love, he's great on special teams, and that's a phase of the game that should not be overlooked. But that's it. He's not a guy who should have the ball in his hands with the game on the line. He's a great gunner, but he's extremely limited as a receiver and a runner.
I'm not going to call out the defense though, as some are. They were dealt a big blow before the game and had some rough early going. But despite that adversity, they were able to pull it together, get some stops, and limit the Bills to three points from early in the second quarter until late in the fourth quarter when the botched fake punt put their backs to the wall. I'll give them some props for responding the way they did instead of falling apart.
All in all, a very frustrating loss of a winnable game. Three big turnovers, two of which led directly to 14 points for the Bills, and another one that iced the game for them were too much to overcome. With a QB like Keenum, we are not good enough to win when we lose the turnover battle, at least not when we are on the wrong end of a 3-0 turnover ratio.