honestly, im not even sure exactly what youre saying or what your point is, but seems to be that youre trying to say i dont think preseason production matters? if thats the case, thats not what i mean at all. Sure every year theres preseason warriors that are out of the lg within a year or 2, but theres also ppl that make a name for themself and carry over to a good career. Im not saying McCutcheon is either of those, to me the jury is still out.
all im saying is tutu and mccutcheon both had good preseason games their rookie years, and neither has done anything yet in a real nfl game. But tutu had the better college career/tape and looked good enough in practice to warrant not playing preseason games, which mcvay notoriously sits starters/ key contributors. IMO, theres really nothing to suggest mccutheon is higher than tutu other than recency bias of his preseason production