- Joined
- Jan 14, 2013
- Messages
- 30,537
Agreed. I wrote it off as someone who just has a personal hatred for him.
Look at this quote, it's what I was eluding too earlier about age... any truth? How old were some of the greats when they got drafted?
"Kupp is already older than Allen Robinson and Brandin Cooks. The track record of WRs entering the league at age 23 or older is horrific."
This guy wasn't too bad:
http://www.pro-football-reference.com/players/H/HarrMa00.htm
Is there an element of truth to it? I'm sure, but it's not for the reasons he'll claim. It's one of those things where people use data to try and claim it shows something that it doesn't. I'm sure the track record for WRs who entered the NFL at 23 and older is worse. It's pretty easy to understand why. Guys who enter the NFL at that age generally stayed for all five years of college or didn't make the NFL out of college.
It's no surprise they're going to fare worse on average than WRs who declared early (because WRs who declare early generally are more highly regarded).
That all said, when they try to use it to act as if entering the league at an advanced age was the reason for failure, they're mistaking correlation for causation. It shows a lack of understanding of the context surrounding the data.