I’d love to be positive. I’m excited about this very young team, the competition they’re building, but I won’t go so far as to say that they’re ready to compete. All it takes is one or two major injuries; we know this from last year.
Inside linebacker has a true talent in Jones, interesting competition for that second inside linebacker spot and teams. But we will miss Wagner on running downs.
Our secondary is very young and we will see mistakes. Yes, Durant is dynamic, Rochell oozes potential, THT is my favorite draft pick of the whole draft, and there’s a bunch of hungry young corners eager to champ at the bit. Yes, our safety group looks competitive, and if Fuller is healthy, he’s a hell of a safety. Yeast, Lake, Taylor II, Quindell Johnson would still be an interesting group without Fuller. But again, this secondary is young, maybe a bit small, and if Fuller isn’t healthy - a distinct possibility - we’re lacking in leadership in the secondary. I’d love to bring John Johnson III back, just because of how reliable and smart he was for us, but I don’t think it will happen.
Our pass rush outside of AD is questionable aside from Hoecht and maybe Murchison. Yes, we have drafted three really intriguing edge rushers in Young, Hampton, and Mathis, to add to two interesting edge rushers from last year in Hardy and Kier Thomas. Yes, our two defensive linemen in Turner and Desjuan Johnson are really intriguing. Yes, the Browns, Copeland, and Jonah Williams are another year wiser. But I have not seen pass-rushing from any aside from AD, Hoecht, and occasionally Murchison. Our run defense will suffer without Grizzly Gaines (please bring him back next year?) and A’Shawn Robinson gone. BB3 has huge shoes to fill, and if he can’t, teams will run on us with impunity. A defensive line that can’t stop the run or rush the quarterback will get killed.
Our offensive line could see many new faces, and I won’t count on either Noteboom or Allen to remain healthy. If Alaric Jackson goes down for any meaningful length of time, we will not have a left tackle. Avila, Bruss, McClendon, Jackson, Havenstein, with Shelton, Anchrum, Zachary Thomas, and Arcuri as backups sounds good, but it’s extremely young and green. I wouldn’t be the least bit surprised if Avila and McClendon aren’t ready. I wouldn’t be surprised if Bruss was recovering and still learning. And again, we cannot afford to count on Noteboom and Allen. I don’t even know if we can count on Shelton. I would not be shocked to see a new left tackle next year.
Aside from Kupp and maybe Jefferson, our receiving corps is not a proven dynamic threat, although the potential is there with Chatarius (I will never call him by that stupid nickname, so there!) Atwell, Skowronek, McCutcheon, Nacua, and whomever will return punts and kicks. Again, I say potential because other than Kupp, nobody scares a defense.
Tight end could be both interesting and extremely scary. Why do I say that? Because Higbee could be a post June 1st cut/trade. Hopkins as a starter scares the daylights out of me. Long and Davis Allen had better step the hell up because without Higbee - it’s the weakest group on the team - unlike any other part, a tight end group without Higbee scares absolutely nobody.
Our running backs are young and talented, I’d argue four deep with Akers, K-Will, and the two Evanses, and yet, will they be able to be relied on to pick up the offense and marry the passing and running games like we had with Gurley? Akers already demanded a trade last season. Zach Evans has maturity problems. Tiyon Evans is an UDFA. K-Will, I like, but he’s simply not a bellcow back.
Special teams will be young and interesting, but we will be starting a full rookie battery. There will be mistakes, and neither Dunn nor Brown are long-distance kickers.
And finally, quarterback. Point blank, if Stafford isn’t himself for whatever reason, we’re screwed. Stetson Bennett is not the answer as a starter. Perfect backup, not a starter.
I’m not saying we can’t go on a huge run! It’ll require a fuckton of a lot to go right, and as we know, oftentimes, things can and will go wrong.