@LoyalRam Thanks for holding it down. Tough crowd, right?
I don't know where to start. Let's see...
Battle formations: Honestly, I don't think the plans were as bad as mentioned above. I thought the trench was good, and using the Unsullied as back up makes sense. The Unsullied strength is discipline and tight formations; the Dorthraki's are open fields and horses. I admit they could have did without Melisandre's fire and the charge was too early, but don't figure that it's
PITCH BLACK. They could not see past the outskirts of Winterfell and had no idea of a location and how many were there.
White Walkers: Why weren't they fighting? They're in control of the dead. Each of them control thousands and if one of them die, they lose a big piece of the army. Also, I'm sure the Night King is aware they have dragonglass and Valyrian steel from previous battles. And let's be honest, they didn't need to! The dead was enough!
Dragons: why didn't they burn most of the dead at first? Let's not forget the goal is to kill the Night King. He could have came from anywhere. But most importantly, it was
DARK AND THEY COULDN'T SEE. Maybe the episode wasn't dark enough lol. And when they decided to attack and saw some walkers, they ran into a blizzard.
Deaths: Honestly, I was surprised there wasn't more either. Someone between Jamie, Pod, Gendry, and Brienne should have died, especially fat ass Tarly. All the main characters can't before the end though, otherwise you'll have no story. I see the RW thrown around a lot, but let's be honest, only TWO main characters died in that episode, Catelyn and Robb, and Robb was a actually a minor character in the books and didn't have his own POV chapter. The RW was all about the shock, but more "major" characters have died in later episodes, like Cersei's 9/11.