I agree with that. The NY media and fan bases, in particular the Jets, are much more ruthless than the Rams.ScotsRam said:Hunter has a terrible reputation for two reasons- 1, he's shite, and 2, he plays in NY. If Smith had been drafted no 2. Overall by the Jets and had been as disappointing as he has, he'd have been run out of town by now too. The only difference in these two players is that more people know Hunter sucks.
I'm sure others will weigh in on Smith, but here's my take.abyzmul said:Hi there Rams faithful, Jets fan here. I just wanted to log on and swap some info on this trade, although I won't post and bail, as I like to get different perspective on the game from other fan bases.
So, here is my straight dirt on Wayne Hunter, affectionately known as WFH to Jets fans, and you can use your imagination as to what the F stands for.
Hunter stood out as the swing tackle (or 'sixth man', if you prefer) in a strange hybrid offense during the Jets' 2009 season, and was able to sub for Damien Woody in a decent capacity during that season as well. Mainly a role player.
In 2010 he played the same role, although he was called upon in the playoffs to once again take over at right tackle when Woody was injured, and did a decent job. In both of these cases, Hunter was helped with another swing man, backup OL Rob Turner.
In 2011, Woody was shown the door in favor of Hunter. This turned out with mainly disappointing results, as Hunter was overwhelmed by the starting job. He did show a bit of upside at times, but for the most part he missed assignment regular, accounted for not only a large number of sacks but also pressures and had a disgustingly bad sense of timing to jump offsides. He never recovered, and got worse as the season progressed and got Mark Sanchez injured on two separate occasions after being rag-dolled by pass rushers.
Still, as much as I like to criticize his play, I held out hope that a light would go on with a new OC and OL coach and simpler blocking scheme for 2012.
What we got instead was one preseason game where I never saw a tackle play worse than Hunter did. It was against the Giants, and he was coming off of a tweaked back, but my god was he bad two weeks ago. I don't think he made a single good block, because I re-watched that game twice just to make sure I wasn't seeing things.
So my take on this is that Schotty really wants to use the swing man in your offense, because there can't be any way he would entertain the notion of starting Hunter at any point.
And if that is the case, you guys likely got the better end of this trade, although you won't find any Jets fans anywhere that will miss WFH.
Now, can anyone be kind enough to give me a bit of info on Smith? I can only glean so much from articles, and I trust fans a but more to be candid. I know some of the info about his concussion history, but less about his performance weaknesses.
abyzmul said:Now, can anyone be kind enough to give me a bit of info on Smith? I can only glean so much from articles, and I trust fans a but more to be candid. I know some of the info about his concussion history, but less about his performance weaknesses.
Rammed for Life said:I waited until yesterday to follow up on the game by watching it on the NFL channel. I watched Richardson and J Smith very closely.
I had been hearing some (limited) good things about Richardson and he did have some good early blocks in the run game.
But, he was overrun in pass blocking in a way that suggests he has serious deficiencies there.
And, he didn't play long. Smith played a long time, with various units. And you know what? For the first time I have watched him, I thought he looked solid.
Smith always moved his feet pretty well. The problem was that he always seemed to struggle gathering himself to exert power on the pass rusher. He always seemed to struggle in projecting force to slow down or deflect the rusher's course and even, surprisingly, to stand up to bull rushes. He never seemed to be able to get his power centered or to be able to project it effectively.
Against KC, I saw a guy who played solid. He moved his feet, but more importantly was able to project stoutness and force to deal with pass rushes. I don't think I've ever previously seen Smith do so convincingly. I never saw him overpowered on a bull rush and he seemed to very consistently contain or deflect the rusher.
Now, I am not saying that he looked like O Pace. He didn't. I don't know much about the KC D front, but I will note that, according to the commentators, "the ones" were on the field for KC for a couple of the series Smith played.
What I am saying is that, if Smith can consistently center himself and project power as he moves his feet, he can play a very solid, perhaps above average ROT.
As for the running game, that has never been a problem. If J S regains his confidence, I think he'll return to his mauling ways.
For the first time, I feel I SEE Smith showing what we need, on a basic level, at ROT. I have always liked Saffold, and I think we all agree that is our 2 OTs stabilize, the O can do some good things.
Faceplant said:As others have said, Smith has all the "physical tools" to be an effective RT. That said, I am not sure he ever had the heart or mind for it. Coming in to the league, Smith was motivated, excited and almost confident to the point of arrogance at times. I loved the attitude and thought it may serve him well, but I think ultimately, after being moved over to RT and then losing his starting job, he lost all confidence. In an interview a couple of weeks ago, he seemed like a shell of his former self. I think the concussions last year put a good scare into him too, and no one can blame him for that. At one point, he thought he had a spinal injury on one of those. Scary stuff.
As pointed out above, Smith has always been an above average run blocker. It appeared he was coming along in pass pro, but apparently the staff liked BFR better....which scares the HELL out of me. Here's hoping Smith and Hunter thrive in their new homes and make both teams better.....just don't count on it. There is a real possibility that neither makes the final 53.....
Possibly. I think it's money.zn said:Faceplant said:As others have said, Smith has all the "physical tools" to be an effective RT. That said, I am not sure he ever had the heart or mind for it. Coming in to the league, Smith was motivated, excited and almost confident to the point of arrogance at times. I loved the attitude and thought it may serve him well, but I think ultimately, after being moved over to RT and then losing his starting job, he lost all confidence. In an interview a couple of weeks ago, he seemed like a shell of his former self. I think the concussions last year put a good scare into him too, and no one can blame him for that. At one point, he thought he had a spinal injury on one of those. Scary stuff.
As pointed out above, Smith has always been an above average run blocker. It appeared he was coming along in pass pro, but apparently the staff liked BFR better....which scares the HELL out of me. Here's hoping Smith and Hunter thrive in their new homes and make both teams better.....just don't count on it. There is a real possibility that neither makes the final 53.....
Every single camp goer, and every single guy who has come on the net for years to break down OL play, including former linemen, say Smith was playing better this year and certainly better than Richardson. And as I said--it's all of them. Independently of each other, and on different boards.
It's the guys who didn't go to camp, watch him regularly, or go over games assessing line play, who are saying he didn't improve.
There is far more to this story than meets the eye.
X said:Possibly. I think it's money.zn said:Faceplant said:As others have said, Smith has all the "physical tools" to be an effective RT. That said, I am not sure he ever had the heart or mind for it. Coming in to the league, Smith was motivated, excited and almost confident to the point of arrogance at times. I loved the attitude and thought it may serve him well, but I think ultimately, after being moved over to RT and then losing his starting job, he lost all confidence. In an interview a couple of weeks ago, he seemed like a shell of his former self. I think the concussions last year put a good scare into him too, and no one can blame him for that. At one point, he thought he had a spinal injury on one of those. Scary stuff.
As pointed out above, Smith has always been an above average run blocker. It appeared he was coming along in pass pro, but apparently the staff liked BFR better....which scares the HELL out of me. Here's hoping Smith and Hunter thrive in their new homes and make both teams better.....just don't count on it. There is a real possibility that neither makes the final 53.....
Every single camp goer, and every single guy who has come on the net for years to break down OL play, including former linemen, say Smith was playing better this year and certainly better than Richardson. And as I said--it's all of them. Independently of each other, and on different boards.
It's the guys who didn't go to camp, watch him regularly, or go over games assessing line play, who are saying he didn't improve.
There is far more to this story than meets the eye.
That said, what do you think the story is as it's being presented?
X said:Possibly. I think it's money.zn said:Faceplant said:As others have said, Smith has all the "physical tools" to be an effective RT. That said, I am not sure he ever had the heart or mind for it. Coming in to the league, Smith was motivated, excited and almost confident to the point of arrogance at times. I loved the attitude and thought it may serve him well, but I think ultimately, after being moved over to RT and then losing his starting job, he lost all confidence. In an interview a couple of weeks ago, he seemed like a shell of his former self. I think the concussions last year put a good scare into him too, and no one can blame him for that. At one point, he thought he had a spinal injury on one of those. Scary stuff.
As pointed out above, Smith has always been an above average run blocker. It appeared he was coming along in pass pro, but apparently the staff liked BFR better....which scares the HELL out of me. Here's hoping Smith and Hunter thrive in their new homes and make both teams better.....just don't count on it. There is a real possibility that neither makes the final 53.....
Every single camp goer, and every single guy who has come on the net for years to break down OL play, including former linemen, say Smith was playing better this year and certainly better than Richardson. And as I said--it's all of them. Independently of each other, and on different boards.
It's the guys who didn't go to camp, watch him regularly, or go over games assessing line play, who are saying he didn't improve.
There is far more to this story than meets the eye.
That said, what do you think the story is as it's being presented?
Everyone? No, not me. And I said he improved, he's just not better than Richardson, sadly. We needed a swing guy, and Richardson beat out Smith, There is no conspiracy with this staff. Look, I don't care what someone claims...you can't know what's going on with an offensive line by going to camp. If they do...RED FLAG.X said:Possibly. I think it's money.zn said:Faceplant said:As others have said, Smith has all the "physical tools" to be an effective RT. That said, I am not sure he ever had the heart or mind for it. Coming in to the league, Smith was motivated, excited and almost confident to the point of arrogance at times. I loved the attitude and thought it may serve him well, but I think ultimately, after being moved over to RT and then losing his starting job, he lost all confidence. In an interview a couple of weeks ago, he seemed like a shell of his former self. I think the concussions last year put a good scare into him too, and no one can blame him for that. At one point, he thought he had a spinal injury on one of those. Scary stuff.
As pointed out above, Smith has always been an above average run blocker. It appeared he was coming along in pass pro, but apparently the staff liked BFR better....which scares the HELL out of me. Here's hoping Smith and Hunter thrive in their new homes and make both teams better.....just don't count on it. There is a real possibility that neither makes the final 53.....
Every single camp goer, and every single guy who has come on the net for years to break down OL play, including former linemen, say Smith was playing better this year and certainly better than Richardson. And as I said--it's all of them. Independently of each other, and on different boards.
It's the guys who didn't go to camp, watch him regularly, or go over games assessing line play, who are saying he didn't improve.
There is far more to this story than meets the eye.
That said, what do you think the story is as it's being presented?
We NEEDED a swing tackle, we didn't have one on the roster.Username said:Maybe Smith just couldn't learn the system? Maybe it so we could save some $. They should've just traded him for a pick though imo. That way you're not taking on Hunters salary too. Then use the Dahl to tackle promote someone to guard scenario. Maybe the Jets wouldn't agree to that though.
If the goal is to protect Sam I personally hope Hunter never sees the field. Unless it's in some sort of "jumbo" package. From what I read about Hunter, and from what I've watched from Smith this year, I'd much rather have Smith in there. Guess we'll see.
bluecoconuts said:I don't think there was any major reason why we dumped Smith. As DR said, we needed a Swing tackle, and he wasn't beating out Richardson. He was improving, but it wasn't happening at a pace that was making the investment worth it. He was probably going to be gone next year regardless, no longer the tackle of the future so there wasn't really a reason to pay the money for him. We not have more space if we need, to try to get an serviceable upgrade for at least a year. 4+ million for a backup OT isn't really good.
OT is a position we need to find a long term answer there. Maybe the coaches feel they can get more from Richardson for 16+ (yeah, that's right, I said it) games than they do with Smith. Either way, I think by the start of next year, we'll have a new tackle that is more of a long term thing. If we get it through FA, trade, draft, or whatever I don't know, but I trust the staff will get it done in the long run. Meanwhile there's no need to throw 4 million at a guy to ride the bench.
DR RAM said:We NEEDED a swing tackle, we didn't have one on the roster.Username said:Maybe Smith just couldn't learn the system? Maybe it so we could save some $. They should've just traded him for a pick though imo. That way you're not taking on Hunters salary too. Then use the Dahl to tackle promote someone to guard scenario. Maybe the Jets wouldn't agree to that though.
If the goal is to protect Sam I personally hope Hunter never sees the field. Unless it's in some sort of "jumbo" package. From what I read about Hunter, and from what I've watched from Smith this year, I'd much rather have Smith in there. Guess we'll see.