By what logic?I get the thought process ... it makes sense ... but by that logic, wouldn't things have worked-out differently for ... say ... Josh McDaniels?
Some guys command a room ... some don't. I mean, @Loyal walks into a room ... and you want to punch him.
I think there is a world of difference between a coordinator and head coach.
And ... Personally, I have no current opinion on Ben Johnson as a head coach. As I wrote above, I thought he was a tremendous Offensive Coordinator, and I'm very interested in how he does as a Head Coach.
All true, I just think that McVay kept/keeps everything in houseWe fo t however know if those two did or didn't do anything to warrant that or if McVay would have acted the same way.
Also I'm fine with this from Johnson, his biggest thing is to build a culture and the 2nd year franchise QB and a WR the position know the most as being divas seem like 2 good people to do this with. Jury is of course still out but if I were a Bears fan this would be welcome to me.
I think Brian Flores might have been successful if he didnt get screwed in Miami and then doubling down by screwing himself with that lawsuitI can't think of many Belichick assistant coaches who went on to have success.
I was addressing your point that Johnson's prior success had earned him the respect of the Bears' players'By what logic?
Why was he not 'head coaching material'?McDaniels ... failed because he wasn't head coaching material.
Huh very i teresting. Maybe people will stop writing an OT off as not good because of arm length.
View: https://x.com/McShay13/status/1950281231909683624?s=19
OK ... now we know what physical qualities you value in a woman ... but we're talking football here!Arm length is nice but give me quick feet, solid base and I don't care if they got alligator arms.
Agreed. I love him as a DC, one of my favorites in how he runs a unit. In fact if I was an owner looking for a head coach he'd be my first interview and not because he's a black dude. I like old school leaders. I would have a coach who puts foot in ass when necessary, instead of wringing his fucking hands about it. So he's high on my list, unfortunately for him I cannot afford an NFL team.I think Brian Flores might have been successful if he didnt get screwed in Miami and then doubling down by screwing himself with that lawsuit
Unnecessary splitting of hairs there I'd say. As after all one tends to accompany the other.McDaniels didn't fail because of a lack of respect. He failed because he wasn't head coaching material.
Apple and oranges..I was addressing your point that Johnson's prior success had earned him the respect of the Bears' players'
Your quote ...
'He designed an offense that has been top 5 in both points and yards the last three years and it's earned him a head coaching job. That ought to be enough to earn respect from everybody on that field'
The Logic being that ... An outstanding and successful coordinator should be a quality head coach.
Logical but not always the case.
Why was he not 'head coaching material'?
We can only speculate as to Why that is.
Hence the simple observation that some outstanding / successful coordinators succeed, while others fail.
... and ...
... that makes Ben Johnson and the Bears an interesting 2025 NFL story, in my opinion.
No kidding?He didnt do all that in the first 2 weeks of his first TC though
Johnson rode Caleb last week, this week it's Burden. Sounds a lot like coaching to me.Johnson rode Caleb last week, this week it's Burden
I can't remember how the rankings ended last year. i think it was like WR13, so he's higher than they project him, but they might be factoring in risers from last year and him not having competition for targets and all those things. But it's fantasy football so it's just fancy gambling anyway.Still not an accurate reflection of his production unless it's an 8 team league. Guy was top end of the league in production with a rookie QB and no real #2.
He didnt do all that in the first 2 weeks of his first TC though
Johnson rode Caleb last week, this week it's Burden
Oh no haha. Although you're still correct. Puka is probably gonna make 40 million per year when his time comes.Ah. ok.
I thought the article was suggesting $23m/per for a fringe REAL starting WR was good business.
These WR contracts have gotten out of hand.
No. It took him years to tear Goff down, then not have the ability to build him back up again.He didnt do all that in the first 2 weeks of his first TC though
That sounds a lot like coaching to me. Next week it'll probably be somebody else.Johnson rode Caleb last week, this week it's Burden
No kidding?
Johnson rode Caleb last week, this week it's Burden. Sounds a lot like coaching to me.
I'm not sure all that is the point. Johnson is the head coach - PERIOD. And as a player (especially a first or second year player) whether you agree with him, think he lacks HC material, think you know best, don't want to do what he asks, whatever... He's the HC. You should respect the position. He didn't just fall out of bed and become a head coach. Most have spent years - sometimes decades working to get to that point. Get your punk ass in line and do what the HC says. If it doesn't work and you actually tried your best, it's his ass on the line and he'll be fired.I was addressing your point that Johnson's prior success had earned him the respect of the Bears' players'
Your quote ...
'He designed an offense that has been top 5 in both points and yards the last three years and it's earned him a head coaching job. That ought to be enough to earn respect from everybody on that field'
The Logic being that ... An outstanding and successful coordinator should be a quality head coach.
Logical but not always the case.
Why was he not 'head coaching material'?
We can only speculate as to Why that is.
Hence the simple observation that some outstanding / successful coordinators succeed, while others fail.
... and ...
... that makes Ben Johnson and the Bears an interesting 2025 NFL story, in my opinion.
Possibly, McVay may have done it in a locker room/office type thing. But if it happens on field in an open practice then not much he can do about it. McVay may have a cooler head and not done this as obviously in the open.All true, I just think that McVay kept/keeps everything in house
I believe you are gonna be right.Oh no haha. Although you're still correct. Puka is probably gonna make 40 million per year when his time comes.
I started swinging wildly once I read "Loyal". I hope that old lady who's dentures I knocked out is alright with me using her walker to catch my balance after awakening from that "crazed zone". SheeshI get the thought process ... it makes sense ... but by that logic, wouldn't things have worked-out differently for ... say ... Josh McDaniels?
Some guys command a room ... some don't. I mean, @Loyal walks into a room ... and you want to punch him.
I think there is a world of difference between a coordinator and head coach.
And ... Personally, I have no current opinion on Ben Johnson as a head coach. As I wrote above, I thought he was a tremendous Offensive Coordinator, and I'm very interested in how he does as a Head Coach.