NFL Head Coach Power Rankings

  • To unlock all of features of Rams On Demand please take a brief moment to register. Registering is not only quick and easy, it also allows you access to additional features such as live chat, private messaging, and a host of other apps exclusive to Rams On Demand.

News Bot

01001000 01101001
Joined
Nov 24, 2012
Messages
2,624
Name
News Bot
By Elliot Harrison NFL.com
<a class="postlink" href="http://www.nfl.com/photoessays/0ap1000000208735" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;">http://www.nfl.com/photoessays/0ap1000000208735</a>


What is the pecking order of NFL head coaches? We delved into this topic last year, and it's time to take stock of the various front men across the league in 2013. Eight teams have a new head man, adding another layer to this challenge. Tough choices abound. In fact, the competition is so stiff that the reigning Coach of the Year barely cracks the top 20. So, let's get started, counting down from No. 32 to 1.

1) Bill Belichick, New England Patriots
Yes, it's Belichick at the top ... and then everyone else. It's truly remarkable that he's taken the Patriots to the playoffs in 10 of his 13 seasons, despite coaching in the salary-cap era, when opponents can cannibalize his club's depth. Remarkably, New England has suffered just one non-winning season during his tenure -- his first year at the helm back in 2000.

2) Jim Harbaugh, San Francisco 49ers
Jim has a slight edge over John, if only because of his ability to get the best out of players who didn't perform under the old regime. That said, right now the Harbaughs are 2a and 2b. Jim Harbaugh earned this spot after proving that his maiden voyage in 2011 was not some big fantasy. Now he's dealing with big expectations, as the 49ers are once again considered favorites in the NFC. Winning 24 regular-season games and making a Super Bowl in his first two seasons as head coach is truly special, especially considering where the franchise was before he arrived.

3) John Harbaugh, Baltimore Ravens
The older Harbaugh certainly deserves this honor after last season's magical run. He's led the Ravens to the playoffs in all five of his seasons in Baltimore. And one thing I love about John Harbaugh is his past as a special teams coach. This spawned an acute attention to detail, particularly in that area of the game (think: Jacoby Jones, Justin Tucker).

4) Tom Coughlin, New York Giants
Owning two Super Bowl rings and always fielding a competitive team might call for a higher ranking than Coughlin's spot here. Yet, Coughlin's batting cleanup -- not second or third -- because New York has missed the postseason in three of the last four years. Let's not forget, though, that he's also still the most successful head coach in Jaguars history.

5) Asshole Face, New Orleans Saints
Placing Payton fifth is quite difficult. He immediately turned the Saints around in 2006, and is one of only seven current head coaches to have a big fat Lombardi Trophy on his résumé. That being what it is -- and it's a lot -- getting suspended for a season cannot be ignored, as it dearly cost the 7-9 Saints. Had that never happened, Payton could have climbed all the way up to the No. 2 spot.

6) Mike McCarthy, Green Bay Packers
The NFL's most relentlessly aggressive play caller has been nothing but a success in Green Bay. If there has been any issue with McCarthy, it's early losses in the postseason. That's splitting hairs, though. He's had one losing season in seven on the job, while teaming with Aaron Rodgers to scare every defense in the league. The Packers haven't finished out of the top 10 in scoring since 2006, McCarthy's first year running the show in Green Bay.

7) Mike Tomlin, Pittsburgh Steelers
Deciding the Tomlin/Shanahan/Fisher pecking order was one of the most difficult aspects of this exercise. Yet, despite the Steelers' underwhelming 2012 campaign, Tomlin gets the nod over his two capable adversaries. Pittsburgh has only missed the playoffs twice in his six seasons, while going to two Super Bowls (and winning one). He's clearly entrenched as the head coach here, as the Steelers organization doesn't do knee-jerks.

8) Mike Shanahan, Washington Redskins
Shanahan has taken a beating in recent years in the P.R. department, and even finished low in these rankings last year. Yet, he does deserve credit for getting the Redskins back on track in 2012, despite the Robert Griffin III injury debacle. Shanahan also possesses those two Super Bowl rings -- something only three active head coaches can claim

[hil]9) Jeff Fisher, St. Louis Rams[/hil]
If there is a dark-horse club that analysts seem to universally like this year, it's the Rams. Fisher is the man getting the credit for that, as he should. He's brought a toughness that this football team simply did not possess under Steve Spagnuolo. And, of course, Fisher has 18 years of head-coaching experience.

10) Andy Reid, Kansas City Chiefs
Reid falls a bit due to the Eagles' immense struggles in 2011 and '12. Still, it's hard to look past five NFC Championship Game appearances and a Super Bowl berth. Give the man his due. There's a reason why Kansas City took, oh, about eight minutes to decide he was the franchise's next head coach.

11) Mike Smith, Atlanta Falcons
Smith is easily the most successful coach in Atlanta Falcons history. Maybe that's why everyone gets so disappointed when the Falcons can't get over the playoff hump. Smith's Falcons took a positive step this past year, as Atlanta won a playoff game en route to the NFC Championship Game. Some will point to Atlanta's second-half collapses in the postseason, but that's nitpicky. You can't argue with Smith's record through five seasons -- five winning seasons, that is.

12) John Fox, Denver Broncos
Fox has guided Denver to division titles in each of his first two seasons at the helm, but the top-seeded Broncos bailed out of last postseason in their first playoff game. His curious decision to sit on the ball at the end of regulation in that game gnawed at some people. So did the Panthers' one-and-done in 2008. The criticism might be deserved, but as the stones are being thrown, hopefully the peanut gallery doesn't forget that Fox also took the Panthers to the Super Bowl

13) Gary Kubiak, Houston Texans
Like Lewis, Kubiak deserves more props. He has done a fine job in leading the Texans over his seven seasons in Houston. After inheriting a mess in 2006, the former caddy to John Elway has acquitted himself well as a head man, leading the franchise to its first playoff berth in 2011 (with a third-string quarterback in T.J. Yates down the stretch) and following up with a 12-4 record last year.

14) Marvin Lewis, Cincinnati Bengals
Here's an underappreciated head coach. He's not the best coach in the league, but he has been steady. The Bengals have gone to the playoffs in three of the last four seasons and are definitely a club on the upswing. That said, Lewis really could use a postseason win to enhance his standing among his peers.

15) Pete Carroll, Seattle Seahawks
Carroll is an interesting case. Yes, he's taken the Seahawks to the playoffs in two of his three seasons. And he did the same in New England. (He also inherited a Super Bowl squad with the Patriots.) Still, his record in Seattle is just 25-23. This season should tell us much about what kind of NFL head coach Carroll is.

16) Rex Ryan, New York Jets
This is a perfect spot for Rex: right in the middle. The Jets have been no less than a train wreck the last two years. Yet, while NFL fans far and wide love bashing Ryan, bear in mind that he led the Jets to the AFC Championship Game in each of his first two seasons on the job.

17) Leslie Frazier, Minnesota Vikings
No doubt about it: Frazier enjoyed a great season in 2012. But he just doesn't have the skins on the wall of the top-half coaches in this countdown. This is not to say that the Vikes can't progress and win a playoff game this year, but to this point, the former NFL cornerback still has much to prove in Minnesota. That process begins with the development of Christian Ponder.

18) Jason Garrett, Dallas Cowboys
Poor Jason Garrett. The Cowboys' head coach never gets an ounce of credit ... mostly because his club seems to disappoint everyone. You would think the Cowboys went 4-12 in each of the last two years, not that they were 8-8 and playing for the division title in the last week of each campaign. Garrett might not be the right man for the job in Dallas, but has he gotten a fair shake? That's a fair question.

19) Jim Schwartz, Detroit Lions
Talk about a head coach who inherited a mess. It took Schwartz awhile to turn things around in Detroit, but he did just that ... only to see everything fall to pieces again in 2012. Is his team closer to the outfit that made the postseason in 2011, or the one that lost eight in a row to finish last year? Schwartz and the Lions must rebound in 2013 -- as in, play at least .500 ball.

20) Bruce Arians, Arizona Cardinals
The reigning Coach of the Year ranks no higher than 20th on our list because of a lack of head-coaching experience. The job Arians did in 2012 was nothing short of outstanding, as he went 9-3 as the Colts' leader. Now he takes over a Cardinals team that is sorely in need of Arians' help on the offensive side of the ball. (The Cardinals finished 31st in scoring last year.) Much will depend on Carson Palmer and how well Arians can fix Arizona's pass protection.

21) Joe Philbin, Miami Dolphins
Philbin might not have wowed people on "Hard Knocks," but he seemingly has changed the culture down in Miami. Much of the excitement this year stems from some big free-agent signings, like Mike Wallace. Nonetheless, how many fans -- including Dolphins fans -- legitimately thought this team would win seven games last year?

22) Mike Munchak, Tennessee Titans
The Hall of Fame lineman has much to prove as a head coach. Nobody remembers the Titans -- at least not the 2012 version. In fairness, Munchak improved on Jeff Fisher's 2010 team that went 6-10 by going 9-7 in his inaugural season. Last year, though, the club went 6-10, taking a sizeable step back. Jake Locker needs to take a step forward for Munchak to progress as an NFL head coach.

23) Greg Schiano, Tampa Bay Buccaneers
Schiano certainly had his moments last year (specifically Victory Formation-gate in New Jersey). Unfortunately, a promising 6-4 start disintegrated into a 7-9 finish. When you consider his experience at Rutgers, and where the Bucs were under Raheem Morris in 2011, Schiano gets the nod over Chuck Pagano here.

24) Chuck Pagano, Indianapolis Colts
Pagano deserves much respect for all things life after last season. Charged with turning around an awful Colts club, he got the ball rolling in minicamps and preseason before being diagnosed with leukemia just three games into the 2012 campaign. That's when his staff picked up the slack. Pagano not only made it back before the end of the year, but was back on the sideline winning his first game upon returning. Also, let's not forget Pagano's pedigree as a defensive coordinator in Baltimore.

25) Ron Rivera, Carolina Panthers
The 2013 season is likely a make-or-break campaign for Rivera. The positive here is that the Panthers finished 2012 with five wins in their final six games. If Cam Newton comes out of the gate fast, and Rivera can coax premium play out of the secondary, Carolina could surprise some folks.

26) Chip Kelly, Philadelphia Eagles
Kelly carries a tremendous advantage into his initial foray as an NFL head coach: unpredictability. No one knows what the former Oregon Ducks boss is going to do offensively at the pro level -- or who he's going with at quarterback, for that matter. There's a lot more to the consensus 2010 college coach of the year than being a variable, though: He's generated an air of excitement in Philadelphia that's been absent for years.

27) Marc Trestman, Chicago Bears
Chicago might have won this offseason's award for "most unusual hire." One of the most intriguing aspects of Trestman joining the Bears is that he's the franchise's first offensive-minded head coach since Mike Ditka departed after the 1992 season (and even labeling Ditka in that manner is a stretch). Trestman has a TON of NFL experience, with the bright spots being his offensive-coordinator work with the 49ers in the mid '90s and the Raiders in the early 2000s.

28) Doug Marrone, Buffalo Bills
Most NFL fans don't seem to know much about Marrone, other than the fact that he was coaching Syracuse the last few years. What most people don't know is that he was Asshole Face's offensive coordinator in New Orleans from 2006 to 2008. The Saints' offensive rankings in those years: first, fourth and fourth. (AP Photo/Bill Wippert)

29) Mike McCoy, San Diego Chargers
McCoy brings versatility to the table in San Diego. Just think about what the new Chargers head coach has done over the past two seasons ... In 2010, he adapted the Broncos' offense to a zone-read scheme on the fly, catering to Tim Tebow's skill set. Last season, he formed the offense around Peyton Manning. Slight difference, but McCoy helped make the transition seamless. Now he inherits Philip Rivers, whose game has waned the last two years.

30) Gus Bradley, Jacksonville Jaguars
So, 30th just doesn't seem fair to Bradley. The former Seahawks defensive coordinator should do wonders for a Jaguars D that struggled up front. Unfortunately, Bradley gets rated behind all but one of the other new head coaches, mostly because of the situation he inherits, starting with a big question mark at quarterback. The fact that he hasn't been a head coach before also factors into this ranking. Again, though, he was outstanding in Seattle, where his defense led the NFL in points allowed last season.

31) Rob Chudzinski, Cleveland Browns
After spending the last two seasons in Carolina developing an offense around the superior athleticism of Cam Newton, Chudzinski has the tall task of getting Brandon Weeden to take the next step. He's also leading a team that's been in the AFC North cellar seven of the last 10 seasons. It's worth noting that Chudzinski was Cleveland's offensive coordinator when the Browns went 10-6 in 2007. Hey, he squeezed 29 touchdowns out of Derek Anderson, so anything is possible.

32) Dennis Allen, Oakland Raiders
Someone has to hold down the cellar spot. Allen earns the dubious distinction after a miserable 2012 season in Oakland. Was it Allen's fault? Not necessarily, as the roster he inherited wasn't exactly the 1976 Raiders. Then again, neither was the Colts' roster, and look what Chuck Pagano and Bruce Arians accomplished in Indy. Allen's area of expertise is on the defensive side of the ball, so it was especially disconcerting to see Oakland allow 27.7 points per game last year.
 

CGI_Ram

Hamburger Connoisseur
Moderator
Joined
Jun 28, 2010
Messages
48,202
Name
Burger man
I'd put Fisher ahead of Bellichick and Payton. You can't rank cheaters that high.

I'd also argue Jim Harbaugh hasn't earned his stripes yet to be ranked that high.

Shanahan? He's been horrible without Elway.

To me; It is offensive to rank a known and convicted cheater (Bellichick) among the elite. His entire record is tarnished.
 

Ram Quixote

Knight Errant
Joined
Jul 10, 2010
Messages
2,923
Name
Tim
CGI_Ram said:
I'd put Fisher ahead of Bellichick and Payton. You can't rank cheaters that high.

I'd also argue Jim Harbaugh hasn't earned his stripes yet to be ranked that high.

Shanahan? He's been horrible without Elway.

To me; It is offensive to rank a known and convicted cheater (Bellichick) among the elite. His entire record is tarnished.
It raises a point: why has the media white-washed Bellichik and the cheating? Is winning all that ever matters? Even when some of that winning was achieved by cheating? :slap!:

Not to mention the favorable officiating they received for 3 SEASONS + SB36. When their CBs could no longer hold receivers with impunity, they stopped winning playoff games (2005) because his defense lost its edge.
 

CGI_Ram

Hamburger Connoisseur
Moderator
Joined
Jun 28, 2010
Messages
48,202
Name
Burger man
Ram Quixote said:
CGI_Ram said:
I'd put Fisher ahead of Bellichick and Payton. You can't rank cheaters that high.

I'd also argue Jim Harbaugh hasn't earned his stripes yet to be ranked that high.

Shanahan? He's been horrible without Elway.

To me; It is offensive to rank a known and convicted cheater (Bellichick) among the elite. His entire record is tarnished.
It raises a point: why has the media white-washed Bellichik and the cheating? Is winning all that ever matters? Even when some of that winning was achieved by cheating? :slap!:

Not to mention the favorable officiating they received for 3 SEASONS + SB36. When their CBs could no longer hold receivers with impunity, they stopped winning playoff games (2005) because his defense lost its edge.

Man o man... No doubt.

And... Pete Rose is banished from the HOF.

It's whack!

Bellichick is a certified cheat and he's given a pass?




Sent from my GT-N7100 using Tapatalk 2
 

albefree69

Hall of Fame
Joined
Sep 22, 2012
Messages
4,512
Name
Alan
We'll know the fix is in if Belicheat goes to the HOF. What a travesty that would be.
 

den-the-coach

Fifty-four Forty or Fight
Rams On Demand Sponsor
Joined
Jan 16, 2013
Messages
22,487
Name
Dennis
CGI_Ram said:
I'd also argue Jim Harbaugh hasn't earned his stripes yet to be ranked that high.


Have to disagree here as much I would love to agree...Harbaugh was head coach at an unknown university (San Diego) and put it on the map. He took over a sad song at Stanford and made it much, much better. And the 49ers were a whisker away from winning their sixth Super Bowl...Sorry CGI, he's one hell of a Head Football Coach.
 

nighttrain

Legend
Joined
Jan 12, 2013
Messages
9,216
Ram Quixote said:
CGI_Ram said:
I'd put Fisher ahead of Bellichick and Payton. You can't rank cheaters that high.

I'd also argue Jim Harbaugh hasn't earned his stripes yet to be ranked that high.

Shanahan? He's been horrible without Elway.

To me; It is offensive to rank a known and convicted cheater (Bellichick) among the elite. His entire record is tarnished.
It raises a point: why has the media white-washed Bellichik and the cheating? Is winning all that ever matters? Even when some of that winning was achieved by cheating? :slap!:

Not to mention the favorable officiating they received for 3 SEASONS + SB36. When their CBs could no longer hold receivers with impunity, they stopped winning playoff games (2005) because his defense lost its edge.
Both of you raise good points, Media darlings are hard to dethrone. That's all it is
train
 

nighttrain

Legend
Joined
Jan 12, 2013
Messages
9,216
den-the-coach said:
CGI_Ram said:
I'd also argue Jim Harbaugh hasn't earned his stripes yet to be ranked that high.


Have to disagree here as much I would love to agree...Harbaugh was head coach at an unknown university (San Diego) and put it on the map. He took over a sad song at Stanford and made it much, much better. And the 49ers were a whisker away from winning their sixth Super Bowl...Sorry CGI, he's one hell of a Head Football Coach.
unknown? Sand Diego State, the alma mater of the great Marshall Faulk.

Faulk way ahead of Harbaugh coach. With all due respect
train
 

Ram Quixote

Knight Errant
Joined
Jul 10, 2010
Messages
2,923
Name
Tim
den-the-coach said:
CGI_Ram said:
I'd also argue Jim Harbaugh hasn't earned his stripes yet to be ranked that high.


Have to disagree here as much I would love to agree...Harbaugh was head coach at an unknown university (San Diego) and put it on the map. He took over a sad song at Stanford and made it much, much better. And the 49ers were a whisker away from winning their sixth Super Bowl...Sorry CGI, he's one hell of a Head Football Coach.
Even so, those tantrums he pulls are going to cause him problems. They make it so easy for us to devalue him, not to mention the hate.

One game, he's going to piss off a zebra and it'll cost his team. I'm surprised it hasn't happened already.
 

FRO

Legend
Joined
Jun 1, 2013
Messages
5,308
I'd personally rank Fisher higher. He is a great HC who is building something special here. I have a few problems with this list though. Marvin Lewis is ranked way too low. Guy is a top 5 coach. Winning is one thing. Winning with bad ownership is next to impossible. Fisher did it in Tennessee. Lewis is doing it with the Bengals. My second problem is rating the Harbaughs above Tom Coughlin. He has 2 rings. Has been sucessful everywhere he has gone.
 

jsimcox

Pro Bowler
Joined
Mar 11, 2012
Messages
1,378
Name
Jamie
FRO said:
My second problem is rating the Harbaughs above Tom Coughlin.
Agreed, it's really ridiculous how infatuated the media becomes with certain players/teams and in this case coaches, just because of a small amount of recent success. Show me sustained success for over a decade from the Harbaughs before you lump them in with the great coaches in the league, i.e Fisher, Coughlin
 

Thordaddy

Binding you with ancient logic
Joined
Apr 5, 2012
Messages
10,462
Name
Rich
Lotta good coaches there and where they rank ,ardunno, as I read through the list I was looking for who I thought would be out of a job next year.You KNOW 6 or so will be
 

Rabid Ram

Legend
Joined
Mar 13, 2013
Messages
7,360
Name
Dustin
Yea john harbaugh is ranked to high

1 only been in the NFL 2 years this is not a list of previous accomplishments so past dont account for anything. If they did fisher and Coughlin would be much higher.

2 jim harbaugh proved last year he was a better coach who won the Sb again.
 

LesBaker

Mr. Savant
Joined
Aug 23, 2012
Messages
17,460
Name
Les
I think that the "brothers facing off in the SB" added a lot of juice to their images. It provided a lot of media chatter and the media loves to chatter and that added some juice to the "public perception". I think they are ranked here on potential. Whereas Coughlin has actually done it and therefore should be above them both.

The problem with this ranking is that they have the brothers 2 and 3 and putting Coughlin above them would mean he is the second best in the NFL and I dunno if that's true.

I also think Garrett is rated to highly. Yeah he works for a dysfunctional club with a meddling egotistical owner but he has had some serious talent on that roster and can't get above 500 and into the playoffs. Now that said the two worst jobs in the NFL right now are HC and QB for the Cowboys and it'll stay that way until Jerrah doesn't own that team anymore.

I was also a little surprised to see Shanahan rated that highly considering he's done nothing and has had plenty spent on the roster. He's involved in shaping it and isn't doing a great job. He has a meddling owner too but he hasn't done anything until this year and he almost got his franchise player killed. He's an average coach IMO and I don't see him at #8. And no way in hell is he better than Fisher. After his first tow years in DC I remember reading a story about coaches in the hot seat and he was one of them. If he's below 500 again I bet he gets the axe. Snyder is that kinda guy IMO.
 

Selassie I

H. I. M.
Moderator
Joined
Jun 23, 2010
Messages
17,683
Name
Haole
I can honestly say that if I was able to choose any coach on that list to start my franchise with. I would pick Fisher.
 

LesBaker

Mr. Savant
Joined
Aug 23, 2012
Messages
17,460
Name
Les
Selassie I said:
I can honestly say that if I was able to choose any coach on that list to start my franchise with. I would pick Fisher.

I'm good with The Fish, no denying he is a great talent.

But I would take Mr. Bill.
 

Rabid Ram

Legend
Joined
Mar 13, 2013
Messages
7,360
Name
Dustin
LesBaker said:
Selassie I said:
I can honestly say that if I was able to choose any coach on that list to start my franchise with. I would pick Fisher.

I'm good with The Fish, no denying he is a great talent.

But I would take Mr. Bill.
As in billacheat no thanx
 

The Rammer

ESPN Draft Guru
Joined
Sep 15, 2011
Messages
2,400
Name
Rick
albefree69 said:
We'll know the fix is in if Belicheat goes to the HOF. What a travesty that would be.
Please don't even mention that...... You know it's going to happen one day but I hope it don't. What a Belicheat!
 

-X-

Medium-sized Lebowski
Joined
Jun 20, 2010
Messages
35,576
Name
The Dude
If Bellyfat ever became HC of this team, I'd have to seriously reevaluate the status of my fan card.


.


Sent via Tapatalk2.
 

den-the-coach

Fifty-four Forty or Fight
Rams On Demand Sponsor
Joined
Jan 16, 2013
Messages
22,487
Name
Dennis
X said:
If Bellyfat ever became HC of this team, I'd have to seriously reevaluate the status of my fan card.


.

Until he won the Rams a Super Bowl...Then resubmit in 30 days for further evaluation.