I’ve come to believe that McVay is not the playcalling Alpha in this league.
He’s certainly good at it, one of the better overall X’s and O’s guys around the league in terms of the passing game and scheming players open etc. I think there are better offensive minds around the league, young and old.
Where I believe he’s shown to be an Alpha is in leadership, motivation, managing a team and pretty much everything involved with being a HC of an entire roster and a coaching staff.
His handling of both veteran and young players is seamless. The way his teams respond to adversity is tremendous.
Culture building.
I don’t think anyone rivals McVay in this way except for maybe Tomlin.
He’s always referred to as the young offensive genius. I dare say he might be a little overrated there, but I don’t think he gets near enough credit for being a HC of an entire team.
This nails it. McVay is unparalleled as a culture builder, and it cannot be overemphasized how important that is. Compare that to someone like Martz, who was a good offensive mind but was horrible at building and maintaining a culture of winning.
He's also a pretty good X's and O's guy, although not necessarily the best in the league. Very good, but not #1.
I think his biggest flaws are in playcalling and more generally, adjusting to the moment and the flow of the game (the red zone issues are a prime example). In particular, I think he's too often unwilling to just take what the defense gives him. That's where he needs to improve, but if he can indeed improve there, he can be in the running for best coach in the NFL and near (if not at) the top for all time.