HE WITH HORNS
Hall of Fame
Well, Mannion looked decent today, but let's see what happens in the rest of the season. If we put Mannion as the starter next week, then it's basically a give up move, and the rest of the team might quit trying as well.
Sean Mannion
- Thread starter nighttrain
- Start date
-
To unlock all of features of Rams On Demand please take a brief moment to register. Registering is not only quick and easy, it also allows you access to additional features such as live chat, private messaging, and a host of other apps exclusive to Rams On Demand.
Agreed...I would feel better if Havenstein was back and then Reynolds to LG and go with Mannion, he truly could not be any worse.
No, playing Foles is the give up move and the jury is still out on Keenum.
I guess I don't understand what they would be giving up. I'm not saying I'm right but do you think the rest of the team would have a problem with trying a QB we drafted in the 3rd round with what we've seen out of the position? We wouldn't be giving up on playoffs - those are pretty well out of reach.
I'm with you, but then again I'm not a fan of Keenum. IMO the dude is a backup at best. So, yeah, how in the F can this staff not come to the conclusion that starting Mannion is best for this team long-term? Keenum must look like Joe Montana with the scout teams in practice for Fisher to like him that much...
Very true. But the logic still favors playing the kid to see if he can be more than that. Particularly given how bad the other two have been.
If he's got a handle on the playbook, sure.
If he doesn't, do you really wanna scale down this offense?
So what you're saying is that all three of our QBs are back-ups? Awe man - we're screwed. Think I'll eat some worms.
It's interesting, I got the feeling from Fish's presser - y'know, the one where he apparently told everyone to go fuck themselves - that Mannion will start getting some practice reps and I wouldn't be shocked to see him play if Keenum doesn't show anything.
He also specifically said that Mannion isn't ready. So there's that.
Mannion hasn't taken any meaningful reps since training camp and getting his feet wet in mop up duty against a prevent laid back defense doesn't change that.
Probably. He's gotta be done with Foles right about now.
For, like, ever.
I think they should start Keenum next week and begin prepping Mannion immediately for the home game vs Detroit in 2 weeks.
SuperMan28
Hall of Fame
I don't think Nick Foles is ready either.
Man. I would always hope for the best for Rams players and I know you do too but I just can't see how anyone can watch him play and want to watch him under center. I haven't seen enough of Keenum and didn't watch Mannion play today so I really can't say which would be better to have in. I sure would however like to see Mannion take some meaningful snaps. It may be selfish as he is our hometown boy but I just want to see what he can do. Right now I just picture him to have the most upside.
Mannion isn't a back up, he is a developmental QB. There is a difference. I don't think there was any expectation that Mannion would see the field this year. Remains to be seen whether he develops.
Yeah. What I hope, or want, or think about Foles doesn't mean spit to Fisher, and I just think he's done with him. I went back and watched Keenum on NFL Rewind (on the Texans), and I think he can be decent. But ONLY if his confidence is up and he's able to feed off the excitement. He's not gonna look any better than anyone else if this team gets in a hole early, IMO.
I was against putting Mannion in simply because he hasn't gotten any meaningful reps this year (in practice or games) and he might do poorly. But a lot of people have already made the point that it really can't get any worse. At least if we lose badly with Mannion, the angst around here will be less severe. Because, after all, everyone will have gotten what they wanted. On the flip side of that, I don't know if I'll be able to stomach all the "I'm smarter than Fisher, because I would have played him 4 weeks ago" comments if we actually win with him behind center. lol.