The problem with Murray
1. Can't read defenses
2. Can't read defenses
3. Can't go through his progression past two
4. Lack of maturity
5. Not a team leader
6. Struggles to play in the pocket
7. Lack of height (5'10") Russell Wilson is taller
8. Hit him a couple of times and he plays scared
9. When things go wrong he pouts
10. Injury history, doesn't play through dings
11. He can't carry a team's offense as Stafford did in the Super Bowl with no run game and only one WR.
Conclusion: He's more than flawed, so make him the highest-paid QB in history!!!! Fully guaranteed!!!
Tua is a better QB his game is just different. Tua is showing progress in reading defenses while Kyler isn't. Tua is 6'1" which is short by NFL standards but not like Kyler. Tua can throw deep with accuracy when needed. Realistically if a QB's game is throwing within 25 yds, with timing, strength, and accuracy that's really good enough to win with and Tua can do that. Kyler's game is throwing 95% of his passes within 10 yards. Yes, he can throw deep with strength and accuracy but that isn't his game and doesn't do it often because he struggles to read it. It has to be his first read then he throws it covered or not. Does Kyler throw his receivers open? For the most part he doesn't. I have seen Tua do it.
Kyler is strictly a dink and dunk QB with his passes his first or second quick reads within 10 yards. Tua's game is generally mid-range throws (his first reads are over 10 and under 20 yards downfield) and he does it with strength and accuracy. I'd take that over Kyler Murray any day. Tua now has the pieces around him so the Dolphins are poised for a breakout year. Tua forces defenses to cover more of the field. The Rams beat Kyler by taking everything 10 yds or less away from him and he self destructs.
Kyler Murray overall record is 22-23-1 with a decent team around him.
Tua Tagovailoa overall record is 13-8 with a lesser team around him.