My mini "scouting" report on Brett Maher:
The Good:
I fast-forwarded through the last pre-season game and every single one of Maher's kicks looked GREAT. Kickoffs are no problem, he can kick it for a touchback with ease. On FG's he's a righty who prefers the left hash mark. He's got a real easy consistent swing. He was 5/5 on XP's and 2/2 on FG's (from 46 and 33). Kicks a very straight ball with a tiny hook near the end. (In my opinion, for a kicker, a slight hook is a lot easier to control than a slight fade). All of his extra points were consistent-- not a single one was in doubt, and they all consistently went through just to left of center. Looks like he has a TON of leg strength, so his extra points were a nice easy swing. Only one of his 7 kicks (the 46 yarder) was from the right hash, but that one was never in doubt. All in all, he sure looks like an immediate upgrade over Tanner Brown.
The Bad:
Only other time I recall watching Maher was during his epic collapse vs. Tampa in the playoffs. On the 4 missed XP's, 3 were slices and one was a hook. Frankly, as long as he can eliminate the slices, I think he'll be ok. On the slices, I'm Not sure if the problem was his plant foot, or if his striking foot was too "open", or if he didn't follow through properly... but man, that game was horrible.
Sure looks like he's got plenty of leg, and based on last week, his mechanics look real good and real consistent. Can he avoid mind-fucking himself? That's really the only question!
But just based on last week's 7 kicks, every single one was perfect. Cautiously optimistic.