Silly discussion, for one Warner was nowhere near a rookie, other than that cheesy Hallmark movie about him.
As a first year starter, its Warner by a landslide and not even close
Warner takes over a team that only won 4 games, and the QB's threw a total of 12 TD passes. Warner eclipsed that TD total in 3.5 games.
Became only the 2nd player in the history of the league to throw 40 td's, at the time was a mythical number held by only Marino
Became first QB to throw for 400 yards in SB history, shattering the record of 357
Only 10th guy to be MVP and SB MVP in same year, and only 1 in their first year
Yeah not even close
Best Rookie Season? Hard to argue against Daniels
Best 1st year? Warner by a landslide
GOAT? Mahomes