Before I start this I want to say I do enjoy discussing things with you. You're frustrating as hell, but I enjoy it. You've made a lot of decent points along the way, especially here starting at the "Yep... The offense" part.
That being said, do we know that Morris is actually doing what McVay wants? I think it's entirely possible that McVay asked Morris if he could learn Staley's system and call it like that. In this theory Morris, not being a complete moron, says of course he can. Then we get the first several games if the year. Like you pointed out several times, we were winning so who cares what's happening right? Bad defense? No fucks, we won. Unsustainable performances? No fucks, we won. Then it an fell apart and both sides had to go back to the drawing board to figure out how to play sustainable winning ball. Morris is trying to call more tough defense, but it's not in his nature so sometimes he slips back into what's most comfortable. That's when we get games like SF.
We returned 3 of 5 players in the secondary. The drop off from JJ and the third CB shouldn't be that damn big. It's one safety and the third CB. The third CB. I'll say it again for the people on the back: the third CB isn't quite as good as last year. You said in another post that or third CB options were put in the best places to succeed this season. If they aren't as good as last year, why would we highlight that problem by moving Ramsey to the star and forcing them into being (effectively) the number 2 CB? That's not putting players in their best position to win. Dude can't make it as a 3, so let's force him into being a 2. That's bad decision making on the defensive coaching staff. Burgess played well last year. I think he's played well whenever he gets in the games this year. Why isn't he playing? We don't know, but we'll see this weekend. You said in another post that you think he's put Rapp in the best position to succeed this year. Rapp can't play deep safety. Morris has consistently put him at deep safety. And as we found out during the Ravens game, he plays too deep often enough to cause somebody to slap him for it. That's not playing a guy to his strength and he's either not holding his coaches accountable for his they are training Rapp or they are coach him that way and it's hurting the team. Either way that's a failure of the defensive coaching staff. Which includes, but is not limited to and the buck stops with, Morris. McVay's responsibility is to hold Morris accountable for the defense. If he stops doing that then he's failed as a head coach. Until then, Morris is responsible for the defense and his head is on the chopping block if it comes to that.
McVay isn't going to fire Morris mid season. That's basically giving up. That's for loser teams that don't really have hope. He won't do that. But would he chew the dude's ass behind closed doors and tell him to call more aggressive plays? I fully believe so. I can't believe that McVay is totally hands off and completely satisfied with the defense. I'm not saying nothing will convince me of that, but I've seen nothing to make me think he's that stupid and oblivious (which I realized after typing may seem like a shot at you; it was not, sorry about the confusion). What the defense did in the first half of the season is similar to Stafford's performance in the Ravens game. Bad but with just enough to win it, but still a problem. Unsustainable. We all said, eventually with good offenses if you let them get to the red zone as a part of the scheme they will make it into the end zone. The defense won't always get a pick or a sack and hold them to a field goal or get the ball back. Good offenses will put it in. Then we saw that happen. Now it's happened again. This defensive scheme may work against bad teams and it may sporadically work against good teams, but it's not smart, sustainable football. McVay has to know that and I can't imagine he's going to just sit on everything the way it is when this season is over unless we win the super bowl of the back of a dominant defensive performance. Iterate and improve is what I expect he'll do. Some way, although I won't guess how.
This turned out way longer than I thought it would. Sorry about that as well.
Thanks for the conversation.
On the first point, I'll just say I don't think it's plausible that Morris isn't running the defense McVay wants. McVay brought him in and there's a lot of reporting on what was the intent there.. to keep the core concepts, but to build on it.
I don't think it's plausible because of a couple of main things.. their relationship is too deep and too longterm for Morris to pull something like that. He wasn't going to be out of work this year, he's a respected coach. Also, based on what we know about McVay, he says his best coaching relationships are with guys who honestly challenge him, he talks a lot about really getting into it with LaFluer when he was on staff. I don't believe for one second that McVay wouldn't say, clearly, what he wanted to see on that side of the ball.
So, it's possible that he's not running what McVay wants, but I don't think it's plausible.
I get your point about corners, but, based on snap count, Troy Hill was the #2 Corner on the Rams last year. What's more, he was their most versatile corner outside of Ramsey. He played the star role a bunch, which isn't something that I think Williams can do. Late in the season, if you remember, Hill started a couple of games at outside corner ahead of Williams.
I'm happy to argue that the difference between Hill and Long/DD has been that big in several ways.. including the fact that he played the star very well, which helped keep Jalen outside. The dropoff from JJ to Rapp in coverage is very large.
I understand what you and everyone say about Rapp playing close to the line, and Morris has tried to make that happen more as the season goes on. The problem is you can't *only* have Rapp play close to the line. Neither he nor Scott are really any good deep and they don't have anyone else. The dropoff in that specific aspect from JJ has been massive. My hope and expectation going into this season was that Burgess was going to develop into the guy who would be able to play in coverage or the high shell. Nope. Or, maybe Morris is fucking up and he can play, but they're just not playing him. I doubt that, but, hey.. anything is possible.
There is literally no reason to fire Morris mid-season and even thinking that seems outrageous to me. The Rams are top 5 in defensive points allowed. To think that there is some kind of problem that demands change is wild.
I am going to get back to the end of the 9ers game.
The Rams D had given up a FG drive in a short time at the end of the first half. They'd been gashed pretty good in the second and had just lost one of their two best DBs and the guy who calls the signals for the defense.
McVay decided not to try very hard to get a first down and end the game.
I'm still having a hard time processing that decision.