Puka Injury Thread (merged)

  • To unlock all of features of Rams On Demand please take a brief moment to register. Registering is not only quick and easy, it also allows you access to additional features such as live chat, private messaging, and a host of other apps exclusive to Rams On Demand.
The good soldier got himself suspended for his stupid off the field antics. A team is not going to hand out a massive early extension to a guy who got himself in trouble and then had to check himself into rehab that same offseason.

So you're proposing the Rams are gonna tag and trade him?

.
 
I wouldn't trade him unless a team made a great offer. But yes, I'd tag him.
It all depends on what their relationship is.

How well do they know him. What did they learn after his off field incidents?

There was nothing stand-offish about him. or angry about him when he showed up for off-season workouts and camp.

He laid his body out for this team.

It could end up being a tag situation. But those situations tend to end with the player on another team. Maybe not the first year on the tag, but right after that.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DzRams
I watched the Terrell Owens documentary recently. TO, who was infamous for being a problematic teammate, worked his ass off to rehab to get back for the Super Bowl after suffering a very severe ankle injury. He refused the surgery to help his team win the Super Bowl. His team came up just short in the Super Bowl, but TO played well at less than 100%.

What's my point? Puka could have rehabbed it, put off the surgery, and waited to see if we were in position to make a playoff run. If we were, he could have come back and tried to help us win a Super Bowl. So if Puka really is the person who made the call to get the surgery, yeah, that's shitty of him. It would confirm my instinct that we should tag him this offseason rather than making a long-term commitment to him.
Sorry you're way off base on this one. You can never knock a player for looking at his long term health. It isn't shitty, its the right and smart thing to do. The Rams have been bullshitting about giving him a long term contract so that also didn't help. Puka has played his ass off and kept his nose clean. If Puka comes back and gets even more injured then what? He would be not only risking his long term health but also his earning power if he got injured even worse "trying to play through it". The Rams deserve way more blame here then Puka does for how this has all played out.
 
The good soldier got himself suspended for his stupid off the field antics. A team is not going to hand out a massive early extension to a guy who got himself in trouble and then had to check himself into rehab that same offseason.
Guess there's zero evidence of him doing stupid shit then cleaning up huh? He admittedly fucked up and has been good since. If we all held people to the fire for stupid things they did when they were young, no one would ever be forgiven.
 
Sorry you're way off base on this one. You can never knock a player for looking at his long term health. It isn't shitty, its the right and smart thing to do. The Rams have been bullshitting about giving him a long term contract so that also didn't help. Puka has played his ass off and kept his nose clean. If Puka comes back and gets even more injured then what? He would be not only risking his long term health but also his earning power if he got injured even worse "trying to play through it". The Rams deserve way more blame here then Puka does for how this has all played out.
Comparing Puka to Terrell Owens, kind of kills this angle to me completely.

That stretch of behavior from late 2025 through early 2026 is the only stretch to my knowledge that we’ve seen Puka have any issues. Am I wrong there?

I don’t know what was going on with him, but we know he went to get help.

And we know how he acted when he got back.
 
Sorry you're way off base on this one. You can never knock a player for looking at his long term health. It isn't shitty, its the right and smart thing to do. The Rams have been bullshitting about giving him a long term contract so that also didn't help. Puka has played his ass off and kept his nose clean. If Puka comes back and gets even more injured then what? He would be not only risking his long term health but also his earning power if he got injured even worse "trying to play through it". The Rams deserve way more blame here then Puka does for how this has all played out.
I can absolutely knock a player for choosing his long-term health over helping the team. There are a lot of guys on this team playing through injuries. If the Rams wanted Puka to rehab the injury and return for the playoffs, I absolutely blame Puka for opting to have the surgery instead while we're still in the hunt. You can justify it all you like. I do not care. We're trying to win a Super Bowl.

If the Rams told him to have the surgery because he wasn't making it back, that's one thing. If Puka opted to do it against team wishes because he wanted to protect himself, that's an entirely different situation. It's his right, but I don't like it.
Guess there's zero evidence of him doing stupid shit then cleaning up huh? He admittedly fucked up and has been good since. If we all held people to the fire for stupid things they did when they were young, no one would ever be forgiven.
It hasn't even been a year, dude. You're talking about forgiveness. I don't give a shit about forgiveness. That's between Puka, anybody he's hurt, and their creator. I'm talking about committing a lot of money to him. I'm not doing that in the same offseason he got himself in trouble and had to check himself into rehab. This was Puka's season to earn the long-term extension by staying out of trouble and killing it on the field. Instead, he's injured. So tag him.
Comparing Puka to Terrell Owens, kind of kills this angle to me completely.

That stretch of behavior from late 2025 through early 2026 is the only stretch to my knowledge that we’ve seen Puka have any issues. Am I wrong there?

I don’t know what was going on with him, but we know he went to get help.

And we know how he acted when he got back.
Did you somehow miss the point entirely? The TO-Puka comparison was about how a bad locker-room guy like TO was willing to risk his health and put it all on the line to try and help his team win a Super Bowl. If Puka did the opposite, that's concerning. I didn't say anything about Puka being a bad guy in the locker-room.
 
  • Not So Sure
Reactions: El Chapo Jr
Any interest?
10250.webp
 
  • Cheers
Reactions: BC Ramfan
Although I'm a Rams fan, fuck what the team thinks. If Puka feels this is best for his long term health and career, its the best decision to make. He's coming up on free agency and McVay leaned on him hard and would do so once he came back. Again, the Rams really fucked up by not bringing any kind of veteran help. Really baffling and stupid on their part. With thet said, this team still has the opportunity in front of them to go far but its going to be a lot harder now without an elite weapon like Puka.

Yeah, I'm never gonna begrudge a player for doing what's in their best interest.

The team already does that.

Both parties have to live with the consequences of their decisions.
 
Mcvay in his interviews the last few days seems in my opinion to be over the Puka situation.
Feels like he's trying to hide some pissed off feelings.
When asked about Puka I didn't hear him say anything about the huge loss and how great of a player he is.
Might be wrong but my radar says Puka decided on this surgery for his own good. I can't blame him really.

Regarding Cooks. Bring him in, what could it hurt. Saw him play for SF and he has a bit of juice left. Sorta like Kupp. Not a go to guy but veteran savvy to make some crunch time plays if needed. The experience for the playoffs would have value. If we could make it.
 
  • High Five
Reactions: BC Ramfan
I watched the Terrell Owens documentary recently. TO, who was infamous for being a problematic teammate, worked his ass off to rehab to get back for the Super Bowl after suffering a very severe ankle injury. He refused the surgery to help his team win the Super Bowl. His team came up just short in the Super Bowl, but TO played well at less than 100%.

What's my point? Puka could have rehabbed it, put off the surgery, and waited to see if we were in position to make a playoff run. If we were, he could have come back and tried to help us win a Super Bowl. So if Puka really is the person who made the call to get the surgery, yeah, that's shitty of him. It would confirm my instinct that we should tag him this offseason rather than making a long-term commitment to him.

That was TO's 9th year in the league. He was on his 3rd contract at that point and had already made a lot of money.

Puka's situation is completely different. He hasn't made elite player money yet. It makes no sense for him to risk a permanent injury and foreclose a chance to get paid big.
 
Good thing we have the franchise tag.

Yeah that helps our leverage. If he plays on it, he's making $30 mil., which is about 6x more than he has to date.

But it's also not a guarantee that he'll play on it. If he holds out or demands a trade, both parties will suffer, but the Rams would probably end up moving him.
 
Even if the Rams tag Puka, he could hold out and I'm not sure I'd blame him if he did. He plays hard when he's on the field and I'd like to see him get an extension. But this is coming from my perspective and I sure don't know any of the intimate details.
 
Mcvay in his interviews the last few days seems in my opinion to be over the Puka situation.
Feels like he's trying to hide some pissed off feelings.
When asked about Puka I didn't hear him say anything about the huge loss and how great of a player he is.
Might be wrong but my radar says Puka decided on this surgery for his own good. I can't blame him really.

Regarding Cooks. Bring him in, what could it hurt. Saw him play for SF and he has a bit of juice left. Sorta like Kupp. Not a go to guy but veteran savvy to make some crunch time plays if needed. The experience for the playoffs would have value. If we could make it.
Like your Cooks idea, agree that he still has juice. McVay can stay pissed all he wants but its his decision at the end of the game that ultimately put Puka at risk in a game the Rams had pretty much locked down. I'm willing to bet if Puka got paid, he'd play thru his injury. Players got to protect themselves and its obvious McVay was going to heavily use Puka without Puka being financially taken care of. One the best WRs to historically start off the way that he has with the Rams and they wanna bullshit with a new contract? Very very dumb move to make
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: David Ray
Like your Cooks idea, agree that he still has juice. McVay can stay pissed all he wants but its his stupidness at the end of the game that ultimately put Puka at risk in a game the Rams had pretty much locked down. I'm willing to bet if Puka got paid, he'd play thru his injury. Players got to protect themselves and its obvious McVay was going to heavily use Puka without Puka being financially taken care of. One the best WRs to historically start off the way that he has with the Rams and they wanna bullshit with a new contract? Very very dumb move to make
I agree Puka has to put himself first here. He might be a bit salty with previous contract conversations we are not privy to...maybe what his agent is feeding him. He knows his value as the best WR in the game and he would be stupid not to shut it down now.

The Rams have the money to pay Puka long term. They are just going to have to sacrifice resigning some other key players. Turner will likely be gone along with Young and maybe some of the OGs. One of the guards and Turner/Young are replaceable.

Stafford might hang it up as well.
 
That was TO's 9th year in the league. He was on his 3rd contract at that point and had already made a lot of money.

Puka's situation is completely different. He hasn't made elite player money yet. It makes no sense for him to risk a permanent injury and foreclose a chance to get paid big.
All true. But given what Puka has put the team through, if he chose himself here, yeah, I don't like it, and I don't imagine the team likes it either.