Puka Injury Thread (merged)

  • To unlock all of features of Rams On Demand please take a brief moment to register. Registering is not only quick and easy, it also allows you access to additional features such as live chat, private messaging, and a host of other apps exclusive to Rams On Demand.
Understood. My point remains, though. When you're the top dog, you receive more attention. It would have shrunk the space Woods had, which is how he generally created YAC. He still would have been highly productive. As productive as Kupp or Puka? I don't think so. Regardless, if the point is that Puka can be replaced, we're in agreement. I'd prefer not to replace him, but he is replaceable.
You receive more attention, but you are also schemed open more.
 
I'm glad Puka had the surgery and will be ready for Simpson next year, because I think this is M. Stafford's last year. And the Rams wouldn't have drafted Simpson if McVay weren't high on him.
 
I would love for Puka to be a Ram......this year, next year, 2028. I felt the same about Kupp. But if Puka is not, so be it. We won before Puka arrived and we'll win when he's gone. There are always great receivers coming into the NFL every year. Les has found them in the 3rd and the 5th round for god sakes. He'll find another. If he leaves in free agency we'll surely get the highest 3rd round comp (#97). If we tag him and somebody gives up two 1st round picks, all the better. Would love to keep him but it's far from the end of the world if we don't. #Nameonthefront!!!
I can't see a world in which we don't tag him rather then let him walk. Be that for a contract with us or a trade. We can certainly do better then an end of the 3rd round pick for a historically good young WR. My ask would be a good player (hopefully a WR) and a 1st. Or 2 1sts honestly.
 
I think expectations are too high on a tag and trade for Puka. Two first round picks for a guy coming off knee surgery and a league suspension - who requires a huge extension. Idk man. Either way, it’ll be an interesting story for the Rams off-season (yet again).
I wasn't suggesting a tag and trade. That would be a tag and not matching an offer he may get from a team desperate for a #1 WR with 2 first round picks.
I can't see a world in which we don't tag him rather then let him walk. Be that for a contract with us or a trade. We can certainly do better then an end of the 3rd round pick for a historically good young WR. My ask would be a good player (hopefully a WR) and a 1st. Or 2 1sts honestly.
Me neither.

Frankly I'm getting tired of the Puka is our only hope (not from you.....in general). Kupp was actually better because he helped win a Super Bowl.
 
Like your Cooks idea, agree that he still has juice. McVay can stay pissed all he wants but its his decision at the end of the game that ultimately put Puka at risk in a game the Rams had pretty much locked down. I'm willing to bet if Puka got paid, he'd play thru his injury. Players got to protect themselves and its obvious McVay was going to heavily use Puka without Puka being financially taken care of. One the best WRs to historically start off the way that he has with the Rams and they wanna bullshit with a new contract? Very very dumb move to make
His idea?
 
L-O-L. I don't box-score scout players I watched play for years on this team. You want to base your opinion on a stat (that doesn't even support your argument). I base my opinion on what I saw. Woods produced well in terms of YAC here because of the role he played. We generally had him running the intermediate in-cutting routes. He was getting hit in stride with a lot of room to run. Rarely was Woods catching it, breaking tackles, and creating yardage after catch when there wasn't space. The YAC yards were schemed up for him. It's why his YAC averages completely fell off when he left the Rams. Cooper Kupp, despite also being on the decline, averaged over 6 yards after catch per reception last year in Seattle.

Memphis proposed taking Woods out of the role he thrived in and putting him in the Kupp and Puka role. That would have required Woods to break more tackles, something he wasn't good at it. As I said to Memphis, Woods would have been very productive in that role because of his athleticism and route running, but he wouldn't have been as good as Puka or Kupp because he did not have their YAC ability.

They got YAC in different ways because they played different roles. Woods's role came with more space. Woods was not an excellent YAC guy. He was pretty good at it. If he had space, he could pick up yards after catch, but he usually wasn't breaking through or eluding multiple tacklers like Kupp and Puka can. Even on the play you showed, we blocked it up perfectly, caught NYG off guard, and Woods merely had to find a seam and outrun pursuit. X. Smith did something similar against Arizona last week. But that was Woods's game. If you gave him space, he had speed, good agility, and good vision. But he wasn't like Kupp or Puka where he could create something out of nothing.

The distinction I am making is very much not a "distinction without a difference" when the proposal was to change Woods's role to the Kupp and Puka role. But since you are so attached to the YAC per reception number, let's actually take a look at that stat for the three players. Here's what PFR shows for each guy:
Woods
2018: 4.9
2019: 6.4
2020: 5.5
2021: 4.4
2022: 2.9
2023: 3.2
2024: 3.7

Kupp
2018: 7.6
2019: 5.7
2020: 5.7
2021: 5.8
2022: 5.6
2023: 5.5
2024: 4.0
2025: 6.2
2026: 3.7

Puka
2023: 6.1
2024: 6.6
2025: 5.2
2026: 5.4

As I said, Woods wasn't the YAC threat Kupp and Puka are/were.
So… you want to simultaneously use the role Woods played against him in factoring YAC while ignoring how he produced when in that role.

Got it.

Because I pulled up a specific play where he was playing the slot.. which was @Memphis Ram’s point…
And you want to point to his overall stats.. where he was used differently in the offense… running fewer routes designed for YAC.

2019 is a fun Woods year to look at.. he and Kupp had incredibly similar receiving #s and Woods ran the ball 15 more times than Kupp.

Woods career if he had been with McVay from the start.. like Puka & Kupp would’ve looked much different.
 
So… you want to simultaneously use the role Woods played against him in factoring YAC while ignoring how he produced when in that role.

Got it.

Because I pulled up a specific play where he was playing the slot.. which was @Memphis Ram’s point…
And you want to point to his overall stats.. where he was used differently in the offense… running fewer routes designed for YAC.

2019 is a fun Woods year to look at.. he and Kupp had incredibly similar receiving #s and Woods ran the ball 15 more times than Kupp.

Woods career if he had been with McVay from the start.. like Puka & Kupp would’ve looked much different.
I don't think anybody would dispute that Woods's career would have looked different. It was a point I made when we signed the guy. He was a better player than his stats in Buffalo showed because that Buffalo offense, especially Tyrod Taylor, really limited his game. In an offense based on timing and precision with a QB who could throw with anticipation, Woods's route running and reliability would show out. Indeed, it did.

And let's be clear here, you've misunderstood my point if you think I'm arguing that Woods's role had him "running fewer routes designed for YAC." Woods's role had him running routes that were optimized for Woods's YAC ability. McVay put him into space and gave him room to run (using his speed, agility, and vision).

I'm also not sure what that specific play was supposed to prove. Here's X. Smith doing the same thing out of the slot last week:
 
I agree Puka has to put himself first here. He might be a bit salty with previous contract conversations we are not privy to...maybe what his agent is feeding him. He knows his value as the best WR in the game and he would be stupid not to shut it down now.

The Rams have the money to pay Puka long term. They are just going to have to sacrifice resigning some other key players. Turner will likely be gone along with Young and maybe some of the OGs. One of the guards and Turner/Young are replaceable.

Stafford might hang it up as well.
Nah, they have currently $75M for next year. They can open up an additional $9M by releasing Poona and $3M for moving on from Landman. If they can trade Landman, they open up $7.25M. If Higbee returrs, thats another $2M. So they could easily have close to $90M, maybe $95M if they can trade Landman. That also doesn't include any restructuring.

Then they can get further relief of $13M post June 1st, assuming Donald doesn't comeback, by officially retiring him from the roster. So they can spend all of that $90M pre June, plus whatever they gain from other roster moves, then get back that $13M from Donald to carry them through the rest of the season.

Long story short, they have enough to keep who they want to keep. Now, maybe with Young's age and bum knee, they move on from him. However, I could see Avila, Turner, McClendon (unless they like Trost for RT), Davis Allen, among the guys they keep.

I don't see them paying two OGs top dollar so they likley let Dotson walk. Parkinson probably goes based on him not staying healthy and he might get a better offer elsewhere. Then of course what about Puka?

So they have enough cap flexibility keep these guys with lower first year base salaries and back loading some of these deals. This is where in a few years, having a cheap QB, can really offset these back loaded deals. Thats how the Eagles managed before Hurts' cap numbers started increasing.
 
One the best WRs to historically start off the way that he has with the Rams and they wanna bullshit with a new contract?
I don't know if they're "bullshitting". Cautious maybe. It wasn't all that long ago fans were bitching about extending guys before they really had to and having it come back to bite them in the ass. (Gurley, Goff, etc). Puka has two things that may be causing extreme caution. His off the field bullshit and his style of play. The latter is a catch-22. Love that he's terrific at it, worried because he's an injury waiting to happen.
 
Nah, they have currently $75M for next year. They can open up an additional $9M by releasing Poona and $3M for moving on from Landman. If they can trade Landman, they open up $7.25M. If Higbee returrs, thats another $2M. So they could easily have close to $90M, maybe $95M if they can trade Landman. That also doesn't include any restructuring.

Then they can get further relief of $13M post June 1st, assuming Donald doesn't comeback, by officially retiring him from the roster. So they can spend all of that $90M pre June, plus whatever they gain from other roster moves, then get back that $13M from Donald to carry them through the rest of the season.

Long story short, they have enough to keep who they want to keep. Now, maybe with Young's age and bum knee, they move on from him. However, I could see Avila, Turner, McClendon (unless they like Trost for RT), Davis Allen, among the guys they keep.

I don't see them paying two OGs top dollar so they likley let Dotson walk. Parkinson probably goes based on him not staying healthy and he might get a better offer elsewhere. Then of course what about Puka?

So they have enough cap flexibility keep these guys with lower first year base salaries and back loading some of these deals. This is where in a few years, having a cheap QB, can really offset these back loaded deals. Thats how the Eagles managed before Hurts' cap numbers started increasing.
I will add that if Stafford
retires, then they lose the Donald "post June 1st $13M bonus", plus $10M more. Stafford causes an additional $23M cap hit if they remove him from the roster post June 1st.

So that will impact a signing.
 
Last edited:
I don't think anybody would dispute that Woods's career would have looked different. It was a point I made when we signed the guy. He was a better player than his stats in Buffalo showed because that Buffalo offense, especially Tyrod Taylor, really limited his game. In an offense based on timing and precision with a QB who could throw with anticipation, Woods's route running and reliability would show out. Indeed, it did.

And let's be clear here, you've misunderstood my point if you think I'm arguing that Woods's role had him "running fewer routes designed for YAC." Woods's role had him running routes that were optimized for Woods's YAC ability. McVay put him into space and gave him room to run (using his speed, agility, and vision).

I'm also not sure what that specific play was supposed to prove. Here's X. Smith doing the same thing out of the slot last week:
Woods also played the outside WR role much more than Kupp.

Many of those designed to hit the sticks on third downs.

He had more usage on those routes than Kupp.

Kupp had more designed for the YAC.

AND Woods also had plenty of YAC designed routes. My point is he had more that were not designed for YAC.. bringing down his average. The number of times they handed off the ball to him.. and how much more.. show the Rams liked him with the ball in his hands.

The difference between him and Kupp in usage was driven by Woods ability to play wide better than Kupp.. and by Kupp being bigger and able to break more tackles inside.
 
Woods also played the outside WR role much more than Kupp.

Many of those designed to hit the sticks on third downs.

He had more usage on those routes than Kupp.

Kupp had more designed for the YAC.

AND Woods also had plenty of YAC designed routes. My point is he had more that were not designed for YAC.. bringing down his average. The number of times they handed off the ball to him.. and how much more.. show the Rams liked him with the ball in his hands.

The difference between him and Kupp in usage was driven by Woods ability to play wide better than Kupp.. and by Kupp being bigger and able to break more tackles inside.
There is zero evidence that's the case. If anything, the evidence points in the opposite direction. McVay used Woods in a way to optimize what Woods did best, including how Woods created yards after catch.
 
There is zero evidence that's the case. If anything, the evidence points in the opposite direction. McVay used Woods in a way to optimize what Woods did best, including how Woods created yards after catch.
So… after making a point that Woods couldn’t play the same position in the offense.. you’re now claiming they played the same position?

Dude. Woods was the boundary guy.. Cooks the vert and Kupp the slot.

Those were their *primary* roles.

And their routes reflected that.
 
I don't know if they're "bullshitting". Cautious maybe. It wasn't all that long ago fans were bitching about extending guys before they really had to and having it come back to bite them in the ass. (Gurley, Goff, etc). Puka has two things that may be causing extreme caution. His off the field bullshit and his style of play. The latter is a catch-22. Love that he's terrific at it, worried because he's an injury waiting to happen.
To me, its a huge mistake if he isn't re-signed. This dude has put up serious numbers since entering the league.... anyone thinking that's easily replaceable is fooling themselves. Pay the man.
 
I don't know if they're "bullshitting". Cautious maybe. It wasn't all that long ago fans were bitching about extending guys before they really had to and having it come back to bite them in the ass. (Gurley, Goff, etc). Puka has two things that may be causing extreme caution. His off the field bullshit and his style of play. The latter is a catch-22. Love that he's terrific at it, worried because he's an injury waiting to happen.
His style of play is why you don’t over use him. The rams should have protected him from himself. There was no need to use him as a runner. So often.
 
I dunno why, but I have this feeling Puka has played his last snap as a Ram and his rehab will be focused on being ready to work out and show he’s ready by the new League year. I think the switch from rehabbing and being ready in 2 months to 4-5 months pretty much spells that out.

I’d love for him to stay, but it feels like he will go.