Puka Injury Thread (merged)

  • To unlock all of features of Rams On Demand please take a brief moment to register. Registering is not only quick and easy, it also allows you access to additional features such as live chat, private messaging, and a host of other apps exclusive to Rams On Demand.
So Shanahan is dumb for overusing McCafferey? Was SF dumb for adding 35 yr old Evans at WR?

Hell, they added a rookie WR at the top of rd 2 and he got hurt.

Just shows there are no guarantees in this sport and fans like you, who claim this and that would have happened with adding another WR, is just ridiculous.
McCaffrey’s touches are down more than 60 from last year…
And they invested a 3rd to reduce his usage.
They drafted a WR in the 2nd AND signed Evans.. and invested a 4th in the position last year. And brought in Deebo and resigned Robinson.
The most Evans has been targeted in a game is 10 times.
Puka averages 13 a game.

What in the wide wide world of sports are you talking about?
 
There’s also a disconnect on here…

People who are arguing overuse didn’t contribute to injury are saying Stafford is overusing him.

If there’s no link to injury.. what’s the problem with getting the ball to your best player as much as possible?
 
There’s also a disconnect on here…

People who are arguing overuse didn’t contribute to injury are saying Stafford is overusing him.

If there’s no link to injury.. what’s the problem with getting the ball to your best player as much as possible?

Simple. Offensive efficiency is highest when Stafford spreads the ball around.

Stafford doesn't get INTs forcing the ball to his favorite target when he's not open.
 
Simple. Offensive efficiency is highest when Stafford spreads the ball around.

Stafford doesn't get INTs forcing the ball to his favorite target when he's not open.
Is it?

Is that speculation or factual?

Any data to back that up?

And what is overuse in this scenario? What’s the threshold?
 
I don’t disagree with you. The stats and eye test prove that out.

My argument has been that for the last few years there aren’t enough great/elite/playmakers on offense. My argument isn’t a full excuse for the reality that both Kupp and now Puka have been run into the ground. They were/are our best offensive players (by a country mile). Anyone who thinks that margin is less than that has blinders on. I can name those skill players(again) but no point.

I do believe that the inability to bring in high end talent over the course of a few seasons is one factor in terms of where we are today and why our best offensive players get worn out.

Other factors have been discussed.
For much of the last two yrs, Puka is playing next to a future Hall of Famer. Before that he played with Kupp for 2 yrs. A younger Kupp that is now playing with JSN.
 
  • Cheers
  • Like
Reactions: DzRams and PARAM
I’m glad Puka decided to undergo surgery. If the McVay/Rams were going to overwork him and not pay, he’s wise for trying to get healthy before free agency. McVay and Snead messed up by not addressing the WR room. They wanted a future QB in Simpson, fine. But why draft klare when we already use 4 TEs and then not even use him when the TEa get injured. The drafting strategy was poor. Glad this is happening so McVay feels like a total dick.

I sadly agree with this.

I think ego got in the way this off-season. I get being in a good position, but mcvay always says the second you get comfortable the nfl humbles you very quickly. Its almost like he (or snead) didn't follow their own mantra
 
.

What's the bet Puka's manager informed the Rams that Puka wasn't playing again this season on his current contract and this 2 to 3 week injury turned into a season ending injury.

.
 
Cripes, the Rams are so weird with injury timelines.

First we hear "probably out for rest of regular season" then we hear "maybe back for divisional playoffs" and now we hear "unlikely back even if we go to SB."

I also wonder if there's some bad blood between Puka's agent and the Rams right now.
 
Cripes, the Rams are so weird with injury timelines.

First we hear "probably out for rest of regular season" then we hear "maybe back for divisional playoffs" and now we hear "unlikely back even if we go to SB."

I also wonder if there's some bad blood between Puka's agent and the Rams right now.
If I was his agent?

If surgery was inevitable, I’d do it now.

Protect him from the team and himself.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DzRams
Cripes, the Rams are so weird with injury timelines.

First we hear "probably out for rest of regular season" then we hear "maybe back for divisional playoffs" and now we hear "unlikely back even if we go to SB."

I also wonder if there's some bad blood between Puka's agent and the Rams right now.

If I'm Puka, or more accurately if I'm his agent, he wouldn't step foot on a football field again without a new contract. No bad blood needed. Just business.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Coliseum Ram
Is it?

Is that speculation or factual?

Any data to back that up?

And what is overuse in this scenario? What’s the threshold?

This is factual.

--- Week 10 was the best single-game EPA/Play at +0.25 despite missing Nacua and Adams.

--- For comparison, the Rams season-long 2026 baseline for advanced metrics is an 8th-ranked overall offensive EPA/play +0.07.

--- Last year against Jacksonville, without Puka, they scored more points, and the advanced passing metrics were nearly the same as games with him (+0.19 EPA/pass vs. +0.21 for the year).

It's obvious that the offense hums when Stafford uses 9-10 targets and the defense can't key in on one person.
 
This is factual.

--- Week 10 was the best single-game EPA/Play at +0.25 despite missing Nacua and Adams.

--- For comparison, the Rams season-long 2026 baseline for advanced metrics is an 8th-ranked overall offensive EPA/play +0.07.

--- Last year against Jacksonville, without Puka, they scored more points, and the advanced passing metrics were nearly the same as games with him (+0.19 EPA/pass vs. +0.21 for the year).

It's obvious that the offense hums when Stafford uses 9-10 targets and the defense can't key in on one person.
I like a good stat pull.
But I think we need to see that against a real team.
And novelty was a factor in the Jville “we discovered 13” game.

The Rams have scored 30+ points 4 times this season.. in 2 Puka was hurt.. in one he was targeted 10 times the other 24.
 
This is factual.

--- Week 10 was the best single-game EPA/Play at +0.25 despite missing Nacua and Adams.

--- For comparison, the Rams season-long 2026 baseline for advanced metrics is an 8th-ranked overall offensive EPA/play +0.07.

--- Last year against Jacksonville, without Puka, they scored more points, and the advanced passing metrics were nearly the same as games with him (+0.19 EPA/pass vs. +0.21 for the year).

It's obvious that the offense hums when Stafford uses 9-10 targets and the defense can't key in on one person.
I don't think ww should flaunt beating up on a shitty team like Arizona as if that's earth shattering. It was definitely good but we need to see this done against better teams. That Cards game is a good start but we shall see.
 
This is factual.

--- Week 10 was the best single-game EPA/Play at +0.25 despite missing Nacua and Adams.

--- For comparison, the Rams season-long 2026 baseline for advanced metrics is an 8th-ranked overall offensive EPA/play +0.07.

--- Last year against Jacksonville, without Puka, they scored more points, and the advanced passing metrics were nearly the same as games with him (+0.19 EPA/pass vs. +0.21 for the year).

It's obvious that the offense hums when Stafford uses 9-10 targets and the defense can't key in on one person.
Bigger picture…

I agree with what you’re saying.. a more diversified offense is better.

I think they had BIG hopes for TFerg.. that’s just been a huge bummer.

AND.. I think they erred in roster construction, ultimately.

Now, we’ll see, right?
 
  • Cheers
Reactions: DzRams
I don't think the margin is a country mile. Whenever Puka is out, Adams dominates.
I’ve never claimed that DeVante is JAG or a country mile worse than Kupp or Puka. I’d categorize Adams as formerly elite, aging out when added. Great addition but clearly aging and declining. He’s a legit starter. Puka is elite.

Anyway, you know which players Im referring to here. It’s a country mile divide in talent from Puka to every TE, WR and RB on this roster. Except for 33 yr old DeVante. Better?
 
  • Cheers
Reactions: DzRams
Every now and then maybe - but I think Adams is about to see his normal snap count double.

Sean is going to ride him into the ground.

Disagree- IMO CJ Daniel’s is going to get some more REPS.

I say that only because of how LOST(nervous) he was against Arizona.

Yes I could be WRONG?? From what I saw was a young player really LEARNING!! You look at The Past under Mcvay & rookies. It’s his time to PLAY !!

I saw CJ Daniels in training camp & saw what he brings from the preseason games as well.

The Rams coaching staff was cheering for him after a couple mistakes.He is having a hard time LEARNING the offense.

I believe going into the bye week(2/3) he is going to be getting those extra Reps & practice time in between games. GB,KC, & 9ers.
The LAST 4 games you’ll start to see the Lights start to really come on.He has good hands & now he’s going to start to build Teps with Stafford.

I saw Xaiver during Training Camp.It sort of sucked to see All The Hard Work he put in,only to get cut for a SORRY AZZ Kicker who brings basically NOTHING to The Table.
I remember this Gal(‘s) watching(talking,cheering) for Rams Players.WE BASICALLY both agreed how well Xaiver Smith looks as a WR & how much he has improved.He ACTUALLY (looked) looks better than when Tutu was out there(Miami). He was laughing balls from Mattew Stafford & The 1’s.
Xaiver had 16 catches last season.He should start to get more of a chance.
 
  • Like
Reactions: CGI_Ram