Puka Injury Thread (merged)

  • To unlock all of features of Rams On Demand please take a brief moment to register. Registering is not only quick and easy, it also allows you access to additional features such as live chat, private messaging, and a host of other apps exclusive to Rams On Demand.
Except it’s not.

Someone who is an outlier in overuse is obviously a candidate for more injury.

It’s not even controversial or an opinion, it’s just fact.
Heres a fact, direct hits to the ball carriers knee are more likely to result in injury whether it happens on the first play of the game or the last play of the game. I dont need AI to point out the obvious or to convince people my opinion is the only opinion that matters.

McVay would be a better coach with you on the sideline telling him when to pull a player because he is about to get injured due to over use.
 
Actually, your post here is emotional and not based in fact because you’re comparing different types of injuries.
You’re also describing different situations on the hits.

The data and medical opinion on this are not mine. It’s just exercise science.
They both resulted from being hit directly on the knee, they may have resulted in different levels of injury. So using your logic, Higbee was even more over used than Puka, because Higbees injury was more severe. If Higbee had been used less his injury would have been closer to the level of Pukas injury.
 
So let me get this straight.

The Rams knew he had surgery three days ago. The league didn't know, and suspended him for three games. The Rams decided to tell the world only today what they knew three days ago.

It's a comedy skit, right? This is not real life.
 
  • Cheers
Reactions: XXXIVwin
Heres a fact, direct hits to the ball carriers knee are more likely to result in injury whether it happens on the first play of the game or the last play of the game. I dont need AI to point out the obvious or to convince people my opinion is the only opinion that matters.

McVay would be a better coach with you on the sideline telling him when to pull a player because he is about to get injured due to over use.
If you wanna isolate that aspect of the hit, feel free.
But fatigue absolutely plays a role in how you absorb that hit.
And it also plays a role on how well you’re able to avoid that hit

Again, this isn’t even a controversial opinion, or shouldn’t be. We all know this.
Again, look at running backs lifespan in the NFL.
 
They both resulted from being hit directly on the knee, they may have resulted in different levels of injury. So using your logic, Higbee was even more over used than Puka, because Higbees injury was more severe. If Higbee had been used less his injury would have been closer to the level of Pukas injury.
Higbee was blindsided and hit at an angle.

So, there’s no logic in your comp.

Weird opposition to something pretty obvious and based on science.
 
  • Like
Reactions: David Ray
AI summary From an NIH study…


Yes, fatigued football players are generally more likely to get hurt, especially as physical exhaustion degrades movement mechanics, reaction time, and tissue recovery. Research shows that fatigue increases risk across both short bursts of exertion and longer stretches of training or competition, though injury risk always depends on multiple factors
 
If it wasn't that last run he got injured on, it would have been something else eventually. He's incapable of staying healthy. Still sucks though.

I don't think anyone would have complained if he got injured during a game. It was the totally unnecessary use of puka on a nothing play. 3rd and 11, no chance of getting the 1st down, running it straight up the gut. It was weird.

.
 
If you wanna isolate that aspect of the hit, feel free.
But fatigue absolutely plays a role in how you absorb that hit.
And it also plays a role on how well you’re able to avoid that hit

Again, this isn’t even a controversial opinion, or shouldn’t be. We all know this.
Again, look at running backs lifespan in the NFL.
I guess Puka was over used in college as well, since he was injured for quite a bit of his college career. Maybe coaches just cant help themselves when it comes to over using Puka. You will never convince me his injury was more to do with the number of touches and not a direct result of the hit to his knee. You can move on and find someone else to argue with I'm done.
 
I guess Puka was over used in college as well, since he was injured for quite a bit of his college career. Maybe coaches just cant help themselves when it comes to over using Puka. You will never convince me his injury was more to do with the number of touches and not a direct result of the hit to his knee. You can move on and find someone else to argue with I'm done.
That you can’t be convinced ain’t about me.

I’m sure you “know” a lot!!!
 
I'm not sure about the science regarding your cumulative impact claim, so no debate from me for or against your claim.

I get the argument against spamming the underneath passes. The issue is, he got injured on a run and McVay has always liberally used him as a RB, even with better roster construction. It's a tenuous connection at best for me.

More importantly, I think McVay and Stafford have allowed the crutch of overusing their top weapons for McVay's entire tenure. When the top weapons are missing, the offense continues to score, and typically gets more efficient, proving that it's not a lack of resources or a roster construction issue.
I don’t know what you’re trying to say.
A run is usage.
More importantly a run is usage close to the line.
Doing that, *in addition* to all the other usage.. is the issue.
 
Higbee was blindsided and hit at an angle.

So, there’s no logic in your comp.

Weird opposition to something pretty obvious and based on science.
Joseph 100% had plenty of time to make a business decision on how he wanted to tackle a receiver who made a catch and decided to purposefully dive at Higs knees to make the tackle. There’s not a single coach from Pee-wee to high school to college to pros that teach diving at a receivers knees in the open field as the best way to make a tackle. It was his decision to do such and he did it on a regular basis - at the detriment to the health of opposing NFL players. Likely because he was too small or too dirty to make the standard tackle.
 
  • High Five
Reactions: Pupped
So, you think you can divorce roster decisions from play design and play calling,Am I getting that right?
I think McVay runs a system. Hasn't changed much at all over the years. Certainly he varies it accordingly to his roster, but not sure what player he could have added this year that changes the play selection dramatically from what they are doing, and from what they did last year when... Let my check my notes, THEY HAD THE #1 OFFENSE IN THE NFL.

13 personnel was a success last year and that is what they wanted to keep doing this year.

So tell me again, what generational player could they have added that was going to dramatically change their play sheet this year?
 
I think McVay runs a system. Hasn't changed much at all over the years. Certainly he varies it accordingly to his roster, but not sure what player he could have added this year that changes the play selection dramatically from what they are doing, and from what they did last year when... Let my check my notes, THEY HAD THE #1 OFFENSE IN THE NFL.

13 personnel was a success last year and that is what they wanted to keep doing this year.

So tell me again, what generational player could they have added that was going to dramatically change their play sheet this year?
Again.. simply not answering the question.

Also.. terribly flawed argument.. it’s like you don’t know the difference between 11 personnel and 13 personnel.

Or the difference in a primary zone scheme vs what they run now.
 
I don’t know what you’re trying to say.
A run is usage.
More importantly a run is usage close to the line.
Doing that, *in addition* to all the other usage.. is the issue.
I'm with others who feel it was the hit itself that caused his injury.

McVay has always used him as a RB so he may have called that particular play even if we had a full stable of weapons. The connection between his injury and the additional usage over a two-week period is tenuous.
 
So do you.

And trying to find exceptions is comedy.

The science doesn’t say it guarantees anything.

It does say it makes it more likely.

And you know that’s the truth.
So Shanahan is dumb for overusing McCafferey? Was SF dumb for adding 35 yr old Evans at WR?

Hell, they added a rookie WR at the top of rd 2 and he got hurt.

Just shows there are no guarantees in this sport and fans like you, who claim this and that would have happened with adding another WR, is just ridiculous.