- Joined
- Jun 28, 2010
- Messages
- 49,655
- Name
- Burger man
Would have figured the Bears or even Dallas might have been looking this guy over one would think
Tennessee couldn’t buy a FG last season.
Would have figured the Bears or even Dallas might have been looking this guy over one would think
Well there’s thatTennessee couldn’t buy a FG last season.
Not so sure 7-9 from 40-49 is acceptable, fair to middling perhaps, GZ was nails throughout (tho he did cost us dearly in Seattle) tho apparently he’s been having issues staying 100%
just as the dark horse candidate does, albeit xfl
Ok so that’s 74% before last year, so Is approximately 7-9 in CFBFWIW Zuerlein is 46-60 for careeer form 40-49 yards, albeit last season he missed 6 so before last season 40-54 from that distance.
As memory recalls, wasnt you the one banging the table for Aguayo...let’s hope you get this one right
Yes, it's very hard to breakdown Lirim's actual kicking stats. In my research, I came across probably the same database the article used showing him being 9 for 9 between 40-49 yards. In other databases, he's in the mid 80% last year with an overall success rate career-wise of in the mid 80 percentile range each year. That beats Zuerline who only exceeded 80% once or twice in his career.
You also must take into effect that he's playing in cold weather outside so the ball is hard and heavy. NFL kickers stats are inflated because of all the warm weather and stadium games they play each year. Zuerlein's crucial misses last year weren't in particularly poor weather. Also, you must remember the differences in the Canadian field. The closer the kick the worse the angle because the goalposts are right on the goal line with a wider field creating difficult angles.
Lirim has proven to be a far more consistent kicker than Zuerlein in more difficult conditions and under pressure closer to what he will face in the NFL than some rookie from the NCAA. The college game and the NFL are two different animals and consistency and precision is the name of the game which is why more than ever rookie college kicking prospects are training at academies specific to kicking. That doesn't ensure success, but it points out the differences in the collegiate game and the NFL.
In 2019 he was 10/10 at 50+ yards with a career playoff success percentage of 87% which included a game-winner in the Grey Cup game. His technique is similar to that used by successful NFL kickers. Bonamego is well versed in judging kickers by the way. The bottom line is Lirim's success rate under more difficult conditions over multiple years can't be ignored. Now add in multiple pressure kicks and his consistent technique and IMO the Rams would make a huge mistake if they went with Sloman over Lirim. I think Sloman is destined for the protected Practice Squad status this year and Lirim will be the starter.
Well then, I apologize for such a treacherous accusationBad memory, never wanted Aquayo, never!
Overall Lirim's career success percentage is far better than Sloman's who only broke 80% in one of his 4 years. Sloman needs to prove consistency before I bet the farm on him. He had one great year and two good ones, and one bad one in his 4 years. His best was his last year so you don't know if it was a fluke or has he really improved that much. Are the Rams willing to bet it wasn't a fluke and he won't revert, when NFL history says he probably will? They would be foolish in the extreme to bet on one college year. Any other position you have backups if a guy simply doesn't perform, but not at PK. Sorry I still take the professional veteran over the college rookie.
CFL isn’t the NFL. It’s not even D1 Ncaa.
I’ll root for the dude if he’s our kicker but I’ll tap the breaks on him until he gets to show the coaches something.
Dont they kick off a tee in Canada?
It’s not NFL competition, not even XFLI was corrected by a Canadain member who stated they can kick off tees but, they don't if you look at the videos. That was in the first thread when he was signed.
From memory they have to kick from a wider angle has lines which is more difficult.
They now use the same ball as the NFl
Goalposts are the same distance apart.
All outdoors except for BC with a retractable roof.
I tried looking up the wind today with limited success but, believe it does get windier in Canada. They play uptil US Thanksgiving time.
It seems possibly harder than NFl conditions.
Let the competition begin.
2020 CFL season
Sports league season
View attachment 37937
Description
Description
The 2020 CFL season is scheduled to be the 63rd season of the Canadian Football League. It was originally scheduled to begin on June 11, 2020, although due to the COVID-19 pandemic in Canada, the beginning of the regular season has been postponed until September at the earliest. Wikipedia
Dates: Thu, Jun 11, 2020 – Mon, Nov 23, 2020
So, why did he play 6 years in the CFL? The NFL is usually the place the best end up.
It’s not NFL competition, not even XFL
I think the weather is over rated and if they can use a tee I’m sure they do when the weather gets tough. We’ll see what happens but there’s a reason CFL players don’t migrate to the NFL
I'm quite familiar with the CFL, and the list emphasizes how rare it is that a player makes the jump. If conditions in CFL were comparable, why then arent we seeing many kickers make the transition??CFL players mostly come from the US college system...the same ones NFL teams draft. Have you watched a CFL game? Tee's haven't been used since the modifications to mimic the NFL goalposts. I'm sorry that Dieter Brock traumatized you, but here's a short list of some of the successful CFL players that did well in the NFL
Best NFL Players That Played In The CFL
www.americanfootballinternational.com