Maybe Carr just wasn't very good? And he had his best year in his 3rd season, if starting right away was detrimental in his case, then why was he showing improvement each year thereafter?
But back on topic, if Goff isn't ready now, how's he going to be ready going forward if his snaps with the 1's is going to dramatically decrease once the season kicks off? How will he be more ready for game situations without playing in games? Over the last 10 years, QB's drafted in the top 5 have started right away and most have played well. I don't see where Goff has to be the exception
If Goff is the #3 QB then the pick was truly a disaster. The #3 QB gets literally no reps and no opportunity to play
This isn't a 3rd round QB we took as a luxury, we're talking about giving up 2 drafts to get him