I'm agreeing with you that Goff has flaws.
I think I may disagree as to the extent of those flaws or perhaps the attribution.
Respect your opinion Mac...
I've seen rookie QB's....Marino, Elway, Aikman....seen these new ones Newton, Winston, Marriota....Saw Stafford, Ryan, Dalton...Watched Sam....
Goff looks more like Akili Smith, Cade McNown, Brandon Weedon...than Elway, or Ryan....so, he has quite a ways to go b4 any elite play. Hell, If I'm being honest, Johnny Manziel looked better.
And you can't say every good rookie played in a great offense. Just not true.
How many of you still give a crap about Goffs "small hands"?
So all the fumbles, and bad throws in cold weather is just what? didn't even wanna PASS in the rain...hell yeah, hand size matters..maybe bigger hands he puts that ball on Quick in the endzone....