I voted fantastic but I see a potential for him growing into elite status. I was a Wentz guy. But I have to say that the more I have seen, the more I see a greater potential with Goff. There's the rub though - right? That damned P word. I still think Wentz was probably the safer choice. But what I have seen in Goff is the makings of some pretty amazing pocket presence that I don't recall seeing with a whole lot of rookies - including some pretty damn good ones.
To me there's a fine line between really good and elite. And it seems that the elite QBs have a couple things the really good ones don't have. Usually, that is system, elite O-line, and/or great receivers (PLURAL). Sometimes a QB can make his receivers great but only if he has one or two of the others. And I honestly believe that Brady, for example, is a really good QB that because of both his constantly great O-line and system (and... ahem.... underinflated balls, video tape of defenses......) has been able to be an elite QB without many great receivers. Warner was a pretty great QB with an avant garde system, very good receivers, and elite RB/receiver but only a mediocre O-line besides Pace.
If the stars align, you have an elite QB. If they don't, even the most talented QB is just really good. Let's hope the stars align for this kid because lord knows as fans, we are due.