Chill is a bit strong for what I meant. I can understand you being overly sensitive about it. I think there's nothing to back up the opinion that it was a sucky pick. I thought the phrase "sucky pick" and the confidence that it would continue to be sucky was overly negative, especially when it's not based on evidence. Nothing in the draft profile, performance last year, or performance through camp this year says it was a bad decision or a sucky pick. Nothing we've seen so far indicates that even if it was a sucky pick at the time it isn't about to turn out really well.
I changed it to "not so sure". That seems more accurate in retrospect.
Also, you are correct. Positive opinions typically don't get a chill (or other similar "calm down" reactions) and negative ones do. That is generally true throughout society. Nobody ever tells people to be less happy or less calm either.