There is no way I would rank Newton in the top 10. Hell Goff is better and should be in the rankings if you are going to include Newton. Mahomes!!?? He's only had one year! No body of work to show he can play at that level consistently. Pre-injury Andrew Luck and you would have no argument from me. But he hasn't proved he's all the way back. He was a great QB pre-injury and right now he's a good QB, who has a long way to go to get back to where he was.
Sorry Kurt but too many assumptions about the future.
I strongly disagree with this. Mahomes was so unbelievably transcendent last year that you have to have him on this list. Even if he doesn't perform at that level consistently, if he comes down a notch or even two he's still as good as anyone else.
Andrew Luck had statistically his best season last year for an impressive squad that won a playoff game. He should actually be higher imo.
Newton is the only one I would disagree with. Goff is probably in that 10th spot sort of range for QBs at this point - which is still really pretty good.