TexasRam
Legend
- Joined
- Jan 13, 2013
- Messages
- 8,123
The thing that I hate most about the 9ers is the way Shanny can get production out of nobodies. The guy is gifted. I think he's the best offensive mind in today's game.
And I also hate that the 9ers are scumbags. By that I mean it wouldn't surprise me if they tank in their seasons where they know the talent isn't there. All it would take is a little less effort by Shanny in the gameplanning. This season for example tanking well enough to get within striking range of the top group to get a QB would be something I could see them doing.
McVay is a notch below Shanny as a pure gameplanner IMO, but he's also a better leader, head coach and administrator. IMO he's going to do and accomplish more over the next ten to twenty seasons than Shanny will.
Shanny is clearly a top notch coach. I am not sure if it's game planning. I tend to think it's his ability to implement his system by evaluating personnel fit and then coaching them up. But I may be wrong.
I guess I haven't watched enough Niners games to say with confidence how good Shannys in game adjustments are. But they have a loaded defense talent wise, or did before losing Buckner and Bosa.
Shanny seems to excel at getting his players to execute to near perfection in the run game.
Mcvay seems to excel at play design, especially in the pass game, off of run looks.
Mcvay's ability to scheme guys open and also make adjustments is at an elite level, where he struggles in my opinion is his predictability. For example, screens, Wr quick outs commonly get blown up and overused.
Mcvay has a great ability to project humility and accountability which permeates through the entire roster, yet he does this while maintaining the highest level of standards.
Mcvay's style and strengths project well for long term success. Shanny will need a great defense for his offensive scheme, I don't see that scaling well over the long term.