Toney is a very different player from the three guys you listed. More akin to Tavon Austin than any of them. But Tavon was much smaller.
Agree but I wasn't going for a comparable skill-set.
My focus was on major physical talent and a relatively high pick but a complete and total waste of that talent.
Percy Harvin and Tavon Austin offered similar skill sets; and neither Harvin or Austin reached their potential but both were significantly more productive in their careers. Harvin and Austin were stars compared to Toney.
In their first four seasons,
Harvin had 280 receptions / 3,300 receiving yards / 600 rushing yards / 24 TDs
Austin had 180 receptions / 1,600 receiving yards / 975 rushing yards / 20 TDs
Toney has put-up 82 receptions / 760 receiving yards / 115 rushing yards / 4 TDs
Absolutely No Comparison from a production point of view.
Like Titus Young (mental health), Justin Blackmon (drugs) and Kevin White (injuries), Toney is a huge talent but, through four years has been a complete waste of that talent.