http://boards.giants.com/showthread.php?75970-Donald-or-OBJ
Donald or OBJ
You are the Giants GM. Rams GM calls you and offers you Donald for OBJ straight up.
Do you accept? I say yes.
1. Donald is the best defensive player in football. OBJ is not even the best player at his position.
2. A dominant pass-rushing DT is both harder to find and more impactful to winning than a great WR. The only way to stop a great QB is to push the pocket in his face.
3. Donald is a team player; OBJ is a selfish me-first player.
----------
What's the Rams record the last few years?? Since we are so quick to say the Giants are 6-10 with Odell on the team then how come the best defensive player haven't brought the Rams to the playoffs?
---------
Rams don't have a QB.
The Giants do.
THAT'S the difference.
---------
Yes times 10, simply because Donald doesn't need any other player to have an impact on the game. OBJ needs good pass protection, a good QB, and decent WR's around him also help but aren't mandatory for his success.
Aaron Donald, need's Aaron Donald to make plays, though he is playing on a good line which makes a huge difference in the amount of plays he makes.
---------
Agreed.
Donald > OBJ.
If u disagree u are either a homer or u just don't know football.
---------
Teams double him all the time and he still consistently disrupts the offense by wrecking interior OLs.
---------
Star WRs don't win Super Bowls.
Dominant DL win SBs.
-------
Agreed so why haven't the Rams done it then?? Also didn't Rice and Marvin Harrison win the Superbowl?? Sometimes you need a combination of both to win it all but yes defense still wins championships.
Odell is not your typical star receiver.
--------
Which player is more valuable to a team is up for debate, and another question entirely. Championships are won with defense, so goes the age-old adage, but I've yet to see a Lombardi trophy hoisted without points being scored by the offense.
The point being, OBJ can put 6 on the board from any spot on the field and he routinely makes catches that other WRs don't make.
I watched Aaron Donald's highlights and that was the pick I wanted. He looked like a football god at Pitt. I was only mildly disappointed when we didn’t draft Donald (I say that now) because I heard a few NFL Draft pundits whose opinions I respected say that OBJ may be the best WR in the draft. It wasn't the consensus, but everyone knew the kid had talent.
They are both once in a life time players. IMO if you see those 2 in the same draft. I've thought about this over and over. The GM genius move would have been to give away next year’s draft to get both. Aaron Donald was the can't miss player of the two. He was too dominant to just bust in the NFL IMO. They talked about his size, but I remember Warren Sapp and they said the same thing about him. Donald is the best defensive player in the league after JJ Watt, and the best interior linemen bar none.
Looking at our team now we need both. I can't imagine this offense without OBJ the past 2 years. Yet looking at our lethargic pass rush, it's obvious Donald would do wonders for us.
You draft OBJ and Donald in the same draft and Reese would never had any job pressure like he's had in the past couple of years.
---------
I knew this type of thread would pop up. Only a ****ing fool would take Donald over OBJ. Lol.
---------
I'm sorry but a WR who averages 100 yds a game a td every two games will always be more valuable than a dt no matter how many sacks he can get or how many pressures or how many tackles. His value is limited to the defensive line. The WR has the entire offensive field to do damage especially one like OBJ. Idiots. Idiots. I wish we wouldn't have idiot fans but we have too many.
----------
U don't understand football.
LOL @ u belittling the DT position.
Especially a PASS RUSHING DT.
Ridiculous
----------
No way. If knowing what I know now I would have chosen Donald over OBJ and knew we passed on OBJ I would be *****ing right there with all the other Reese haters and their *****ing would be exponetially worse if that is possible. I guarantee you that barring injury OBJ has the longer and more impactful career. Its just no comparison.
Would you rather have Brian Quick or Kenny Britt with Aaron Donald or OBJ and Snacks and Wilkerson? That's what you should be asking yourself. I would also like you to ask Rams fans worldwide who they would rather fave. I'm just besides myself with the logic in here.
Amazing. Uncanny even. Einstein was right about the infinite nature of human stupidity he is proven right on these boards every single second. I don't know why I keep doing this to myself.
----------
Odell Beckham jr. Is the BEST wide receiver EVER...again.. EVER... through his first 34 games in the NFL. Argue all you want who is number one right now.. I'll take the guy that is projected to shatter every record that exists at his position. If you can't see how much of an impact he has in both production and opposing game planning.. Well you're just a hater.
----------
I love Odell, but i would have chosen Donald, Defense still wins championships, i rather have a great defense over high powered offense and a crappy defense, Broncos won a SB with noodle arm Peyton Manning..
----------
With no QB too.
Put Eli on the Rams during that time period, then put Austin Davis/Shaun Hill/Keenum on the Giants....and imagine how much more the W-L disparity would be.
---------
And Donald is not the whole dline either. He clearly still needs help because they have never been a top 10 defense since he's been in the league.
---------
But u do not need great WRs
Did the 2012 Ravens have star WRs?
Did the 2013 Seahawks have star WRs?
Did the 2014 Pats have star WRs?
----------
If I'm offered that trade I'd decline. Look Donald might be viewed as the better player, however I don't think his addition makes us that much better as a team. Now u take OBJ off the team and I think we are worse. Donald might make some great plays for us and improve our Defense...but without OBJ we aren't scoring much.
----------
Donald and Gurley, then we have a starting point for negotiation.
-----------
I wouldn't trade Odell for the entire Rams team.
----------
Donald is good but the main reason why he looks so dominant is the other first round picks and dominant defensive lineman on the Rams d-line.
----------
Donald. Defenses win championships. Not WRs.
As a defensive minded coach, id take a top 5 defense over a top 5 offense any day of the week. This isnt a knock on OBJ.
Donald has been viewed as one of the best players in the league in any position. He is a generational talent that happens to also play on the side of the ball that wins championships.
Sorry but this isnt even close imo. Again, nothing against Beck.
---------
Casual fans will always pick a flashy WR. Students of the game know better and will always pick a legendary defensive line type of player.
News flash, the last 5 superbowls were won directly by defenses. Not one of those teams had a top 5 wr on the team.