I'm sure the coaches told Karty how to kick. No way he made those decisions on his own.
So out of 7 kickoffs, there were 4 times he was told to boot it into the EZ (for a start at the 35).
In my view, Karty was successful on 2 of 3 "dirty" attempts. One was a horrible mis-kick that landed well short of the landing zone, and looked really bad -- a glaring error. But the other 2 kicks were successful in my opinion-- they dropped into the landing zone and were difficult to handle. On one, the returner corralled it after one bounce and got a good return to the 33. On the other, the ball took some weird bounces and almost landed at the 2 yard line. IMO, you take that kick every time.
I'm concerned that Karty might be a head case. But he's had enough success with the dirty kick that I think they should keep doing it. We'll know more in a couple weeks.
Last thing-- even if heaven forbid the ball doesn't make it to the landing zone, having the ball placed at the 40 is only 5 yards worse than the supposedly "safe" option of blasting it through the EZ. If a team is gonna try the dirty kick, it's inevitable that occasionally there will be flags to place the ball at the 40. IMO, the dirty kick option is still way better than the crap the Rams were doing in weeks 1-7.