The Rams’ decision to arrive in Melbourne the day before the game clearly didn’t work. They looked flat, the 49ers battered them and the whole thing now looks like a total clusterfuck.
But there’s a considerable difference between saying the decision produced a terrible result and claiming the Rams hadn’t thought it through or that it was obvious they couldn't do what they wanted to.
The plan was to keep the players on LA time so their bodies would treat the 10.35am Melbourne kick-off as a late-afternoon game. It worked when travelling to London to play the Jaguars, and they consulted sleep and performance experts before deciding to try it again over a much greater distance.
You can argue that they placed too much faith in the theory. You can also argue that Australia was a completely different proposition from London. And you can certainly argue that the evidence provided by the game suggests they shouldn’t try it again.
What you can’t reasonably argue is that nobody at the Rams realised jet lag existed or considered the benefits of arriving earlier ffs. Or suggest that they were pushing back against all known advice.
This will have been discussed and analysed ad nauseam. They took expert advice, it wasn't something McVay dreamed up after having one too many energy drinks. It was a wacky approach, but even to a layman like myself, there seemed to be a fair bit of logic supporting it. And history is littered with incredible breakthroughs that seemed counterintuitive at the time.
Now, it's dead obvious to look at that and say, "Yeah, that was a fucking stupid idea." That's just hindsight bias kicking in.
I highly doubt the decision was made carelessly. Rather, it means a careful decision happened to be wrong. Such is life.
The reaction to the Myles Garrett situation is much the same with more morons per square inch at the Village Idiots Convention, piling in on Facebook, saying the Rams got hosed by the Browns. Even though the injury happened after the trade.
Everybody's a fucking medical expert, and everybody knows that he should have had the surgery as soon as the injury was spotted.
The Rams will have examined Garrett’s medical records before giving up what they did to acquire him. Once the knee problem appeared, their medical staff will have assessed it, taken scans, consulted specialists and almost certainly sought more than one opinion. Garrett himself will also have had a say in whether to continue with treatment or undergo surgery.
Medicine is seldom an exact science. Different specialists can examine the same injury and recommend different treatments. Sometimes rest and rehabilitation work. Sometimes they don’t, and surgery becomes necessary.
The same principle applies to the Melbourne trip. Elite sport involves making decisions with incomplete information in areas where there isn’t always one provably correct answer.
Criticise the results because both look bad. And by all means question whether the Rams put too much faith in their own cleverness. That is definitely a stick that McVay occasionally needs beating with. But pretending the obvious answer was staring the fucking internet in the face, while dozens of experienced people inside the organisation somehow missed it, is utter bollocks.