Yamahopper
Hall of Fame
- Joined
- Jul 31, 2010
- Messages
- 3,838
jrry32 said:Yamahopper said:Nice work. Great analysis. I know it's hard to diagnose off the coaches film and it takes a lot of time. Good effort. Thanks.
On the dump off to Kendricks. Pettis looked open and he was for a second, but the CB had already turned his shoulders and was driving on him. That ball has to be thrown before Pettis makes his cut inside. It couldn't because the other receiver was clearing the underneath. And that's where the ball should have went. He had the defender shielded and the ball should have hit him in Stride as he headed downfield.
The CB fell down and was out of position to make a play on the ball if it was thrown when Pettis went into his break. Even if he hadn't fallen down, he wouldn't have made a play on it. When Pettis made his break, the CB had to continue up-field a few yards to gear down and break with him. That took him from inside his hip pocket to a couple yards over the top and on his outside hip. He can't make a play on the ball from that position.
That's the issue with Givens's out route. You can round breaks vs. zone coverage to get to the soft spot in the zone or if you win at the line against press coverage because you already have separation.
But you never round off a route when you have a CB in man coverage in your hip pocket. It's one of the worst sins you can commit as a WR.
You sink your hips, you plant your foot into the ground and you make a hard break. The vast majority of the time, if you do it correctly, it'll be enough for you to gain a yard or two of separation at minimum. Especially on a deep route with a hard break such as the out or dig. Because the defender is running so fast and often leveraged inside, it takes him a few yards to gear down and break with you which puts him to the outside of the WR and behind the WR. Which puts him into a position where he can't make a play on the ball. When you round it, you make it easy on him to sit on your hip, gain inside position and undercut the route.
Also, I don't see the opening that you do for the other WR.
On the dump to Austin in the flat...Wrong side of the field. The rec. topside has a step and shielded his defender, the ball has to be put in front of him for a hands catch because he's in stride and heading downfield.
Disagree. You have Tavon Austin in space at the first down marker on 3rd down. Take the easy conversion.
The other WR hadn't gained the separation needed to make that throw imo. We don't have a guy like Dez or Calvin or Fitz who you can take that sort of shot with. What likely would have happened is the CB would have hooked the WR's outside hip and reached around to knock the ball down. Then you're counting on a 50/50 call from the refs for PI. I'd take the sure thing there.
But I appreciate your thoughts here even if I disagree. You make some valid points and maybe that shot would have paid off.
Before the coaches film I had to sit in the upper deck and watch it as it happened. I've seen Warner and Bulger and even Bradford make those throws a 100 times. It's timing and ball placement to where the DB has to go thru the rec. to get the ball.
Both are huge windows to get the ball in there where only the rec can get it or knock it down. Separation isn't only 5 yards it can be as little as the defender behind the angle of the throw having to go thru the rec. or slow and reaccelerate to make a play. It's no more risky than a toss to the flat or a slant.
It's a timing offense. That's what Schotty said we will run. The ball comes out before the break or the rec. is open. It doesn't hope for CB's to fall down or blown coverages. It's practice and trust. A vertical game doesn't have to be mad bombs, just catches with a downfield slap.
But none of that goes to the point why the rec. are just running sideways or sitting down.
The players have the talent. The Rams have killed with both of those plays in the past. It's just a comfort issue that they will work through in time.
But I guess it goes to the play it Shumur safe or take the next step.