GAME DAY Rams vs Renters, Quick turnaround Pre-Season Game #3

  • To unlock all of features of Rams On Demand please take a brief moment to register. Registering is not only quick and easy, it also allows you access to additional features such as live chat, private messaging, and a host of other apps exclusive to Rams On Demand.
I'm not going to predict the future but I will say that Ty Simpson was definitely worthy of being a first-round draft pick and that's enough for me. I wanted antoher weapon for Matt Stafford but, as usual, Snead and McVay know more than I do.
 
Why not compare him to Stetson of THIS year then?
I mean they are and that’s why Stetson will likely be QB2. He’s got a better grasp of the offense and it’s just more advanced as a passer at this point.

Also, I just want to be clear. I don’t feel great about neither one having any NFL game experience. With the potential of this team, I’d much rather Jimmy be there. But between Bennett and Simpson, I feel better about Bennett for the 2026 season. But I think Simpson has a bright future and there is a lot to be excited about.
 
I mean they are and that’s why Stetson will likely be QB2. He’s got a better grasp of the offense and it’s just more advanced as a passer at this point.

Also, I just want to be clear. I don’t feel great about neither one having zero NFL game experience. With the potential of this team, I’d much rather Jimmy be there. But between Bennett and Simpson, I feel better about Bennett for the 2026 season. But I think Simpson has a bright future and there is a lot to be excited about.
Ty Simpson outplayed Bennett this year
 
Turnovers happen when you consistently push the ball downfield. Compare Stetson’s 2025 preseason with Ty’s this year.

Bennett 2025: 44/64 512 yards 5 TDs 2 INTs

Simpson 2026: 47/60 380 yards 3 TDs, 0 INTs

This is a legit criticism. Ty is making good decisions, but he is not pushing the ball down the field. IMO, it's not because he can't; it's because the training wheels are still on.
 
Now show the interceptions and turnover worthy plays
That was mostly from the first two preseasons. The last two have been pretty good.

He had a couple bad passes this preseason out of 20 or so throws.

I don't want him as a backup but you guys are really harsh.
 
This is a legit criticism. Ty is making good decisions, but he is not pushing the ball down the field. IMO, it's not because he can't; it's because the training wheels are still on.
And this was a criticism of his all through camp with only a day or two where it was reported he tried cutting it loose. I think some of it's by design but some of it is on him.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DzRams
McVay already said the team is keeping 3 QBs which tells you all you need to know.

And the coaching staff didn’t even give him an opportunity to make bad decisions. 95% of his attempts were boots and quick game. Very elementary stuff. Bennett threw the ball downfield more on a single 2 minute drill than Simpson did the entire preseason.

People are conflating “potential” and “talent” with “who is more ready to run McVay’s offense vs first team defenses?”. Those are two completely different questions. And the latter is how you decide who plays backup QB.
Well...isn't that what you do...bring a guy along slowly??? You don't just dump the whole offense on the guy and expect him to run it flawlessly. He certainly could have made bad decisions but he didn't.

You let the guy handle the basics and progressively add more as you see he can handle it. Simpson shows he's ready for the next step.

What I'm seeing is not "potential". I'm seeing a kid that shows he's ready for the next step...and that doesn't even show what they're giving him in practice sessions and having Stafford to help him is gravy!
 
We NEVER have a mobile FQ. Since Harris, who was extremely short-lived:

Haden
Season 3 Ugh GIF by Parks and Recreation
 
  • HaHa
Reactions: Ground Chuck
At this point, with Tu Tu back and all that, I would rather cut-trade Bennett vs losing-cutting Daniels or Conners. Simpson might not be quite ready but I have seen enough to know he can get the job done. Especially with our defense. We are going to be very tough to score on.
Simpson is going to be very good and I do not want to lose any young and promising talent for Bennett.
 
I don’t think he did. He was asked to run a very elementary version of the offense where the coaching staff limited his potential for mistakes. Stetson’s 2 min drive vs NO alone was more impressive than anything Ty did all preseason.
Thats false, the TD strike Ty threw was better than anything Stetson did.
0 TD passes
Simpson consistently threw to 2nd and 3rd options
He is/was the better QB
Alas...
 
I don’t think he did. He was asked to run a very elementary version of the offense where the coaching staff limited his potential for mistakes. Stetson’s 2 min drive vs NO alone was more impressive than anything Ty did all preseason.
Considering Bennett has been in this offense for 4 yrs to Simpson's 4 months, Simpson outplayed him badley.
 
This guy Joe does film evals. Loves him.


View: https://x.com/JoeA_NFL/status/2093170555327287492


Some guy retorted "take it easy, its preseason." Joe posted his pre-draft SR.

THAT was a helluva play.
OL'er Blaske preformance on the right side of the OL is far from how he plays on the LEFT.

RG Blaske block caused TY to depart from the pocket. Yes it resulted in a TD .....but I am sure that was not the plan.

RT Henderson can not pass block!
 
  • Like
Reactions: JonRam99