Again, you have to limit some things because being able to challenge everything would be over the top because you could challenge holding every single time. Non calls although some are obvious would slow down the game to a crawl.
Pass interference and possibly some other severe penalties need to be reviewable.
- Thread starter Ellard80
- Start date
-
To unlock all of features of Rams On Demand please take a brief moment to register. Registering is not only quick and easy, it also allows you access to additional features such as live chat, private messaging, and a host of other apps exclusive to Rams On Demand.
Yeah, but if a call is not made you cannot force the issue. I am telling you, it would open up pandora's box and you would not like it.
To be fair, I stated two non-calls. Obviously, holding would be too crazy to challenge. I would settle for a missed face mask on players with the ball.
After waiting a lifetime waiting for the final 20 seconds of the half in the Eagles v Jags game, what's a minute or two for the facemask non-call.
Exactly. I saw that. Was watching that game. Full on pass interference not called. If it was called, Alabama at the very least would have had the ball in excellent field goal range, and an opportunity to win with a TD. Instead, they went down in flames. Poor quality calls by refs are just everywhere and it sucks to see.
So, I'm so confused with replay.
I'm watching the Eagles/Jags game.
The Jags are flagged and called for a personal foul facemask, even though replay showed it was absolutely not a facemask.
Just after the replay and the call by the ref, suddenly the ref makes an announcement that replay assist has reveresed the flag, and no foul.
I don't get when this new replay assist kicks in, or doesn't.
And, I will note it was fast. If replay assist can work that quickly, it doesn't seem like it would slow the game much.
I'm watching the Eagles/Jags game.
The Jags are flagged and called for a personal foul facemask, even though replay showed it was absolutely not a facemask.
Just after the replay and the call by the ref, suddenly the ref makes an announcement that replay assist has reveresed the flag, and no foul.
I don't get when this new replay assist kicks in, or doesn't.
And, I will note it was fast. If replay assist can work that quickly, it doesn't seem like it would slow the game much.
I liked the replay assist that overturned a facemask penalty in the Eagles game against the Jags. I have no idea how it works either?
Or maybe if everything is viewable and callable then we get a fairer game without all these uncalled fouls.
If they know they'll get called, [smart] players won't commit those fouls.
I know, there is a judgment line on holding/PI etc.
I'm talking about the obvious ones we all see on TV that the refs don't.
BC
With the game being faster these days, the NFL can surely afford a 9 man referee crew. It puzzles me how a ref is assigned to watch the QB and we see Stafford (or Goff like 3 times in the Saints NFCCG get the facemask yanked with no calls). And maybe refs behind the play should not be allowed to assume interference like the ref did in the broncos game, and the ref with the best view didn't throw a flag or correct the ref behind the players. Otherwise you're inviting "flops" in the NFL.