While I dont disagree with this it seems Byrd is a favorite on the board in terms of FA to target, that is why I brought him up. Macdonald showed promise, Mcleod (to me) showed nothing and the other two young guys couldnt get on the field. Where is the projection in a very tough division? For me it was year three of the rebuild. The O line is in a state of sort of flux (whats new?), massive progress has been made in terms of the roster as a whole and D in terms of play makers. But, the NFC West is brually tough and does not stand to get easier. If the Rams run out a safety group with 2 second year players backed up by guys that are even greener, well, I hope we continue to be a run first (keep the D off the field) sort of team. It is a work in progress. I do agree with Fisher valueing versatility and how much they run the nickle speaks to this. It will be interesting to see how early and or often the Rams go DB in the draft. Retaining some vet experience is not a bad thing in my estimation. I dont want to overpay for Byrd or anyone else.
I think you are underestimating the year of experience that "the other two young guys" got this year will be in FISHER'S mind. Cody Davis might be the most gifted of all the Safeties on the roster. But I think it became an issue, (especially once Finnegan went down), having that many inexperienced guys in the secondary.
When your starting safety (McLeod) is forced to slide into the Nickel CB spot, they were pretty much forced to insert a veteran (Giordano and then Stewart) in there as the extra DB.
While Stewart was the heir apparent to the starters job in training camp, once he struggled to stay on the field, they had very little reservation about turning the job over to McLeod. While being a 1st time starter, he has spent the previous year in the system, much the same as C. Davis will have when they get to camp NEXT year.
McLeod IMO, improved his tackling as the year went on, but he is much better as a depth guy, who can be a versatile and reliable replacement, and back to being a key ST contributor. For me, I think C. Davis has all the "measurables", size, speed, smarts and he might be the most consistent tackler of the current group.
It just becomes a question of how comfortable is he in the system, and can he be the guy paired with McDonald moving forward. The guy I don't see being brought back is Stewart. If, and I know its a BIG if, Daniels can ever make it thru a season healthy, he brings everything that Stewart brings, and more.