I like what your saying Champ, BUT I just don't see how we can carry 7 WR's on the 53 man Roster! I would like to see how you would break down the "O" Player's!! How many O-Lineman - RB's - TE's etc.!?If we consider the practice squad as making the team...
Woods, Reynolds, Kupp, Spruce, Thomas (dude has ran the most at practice...and they KEEP bringing his name up, plus he reminds me of Ike Bruce)...and Austin??? Then Cooper &....wild card here...North...Bradley Marquez is the shocker....not making it....and Cooper WON'T last on the PS.
I don't see Spruce or Pharoh Cooper loosing out to rookies....as receivers....Now special teams...whole nuther story.
7 make squad...baring a trade of some type...with 2 more on PS...
I think they keep 5 WR maybe 6
Saints kept 5 WR last year Atlanta 5, Washington 4!
Cooper is a returner....KO returner to be exact...and can do the punt returns. ST's is important to Bones....I can see him, just due to his return skills, making the 53. He's also gonna be an improved wr. Thomas is like this to me also. And he's an even BETTER wr. Spruuuuce is spoken of as a better wr than these others...Not proven, but a lot of people think this. These 3 players are the tough, people always doubt type...And I really expect improvement in their 2nd years. Kupp, Reynolds, Woods, and....Austin are locks most think. Only Austin will play ST. Call me crazy....but after Woods, I want those 2nd year guys out there first. Kupp, Reynolds and Austin have to prove/show me they are ready.Okay, so if Cooper and Everett are solid, then who of these six doesn't make it?...............You might be right. If Spruce just seems like a lesser Kupp clone and Reynolds like a rookie Thomas, then I suppose it might be
Austin, Woods, Kupp, Thomas, Cooper, Everett.
I can't say for sure Dave...but imagine if Jamon Brown can play backup center, backup guard, and backup RT? That eliminates a bunch of players for backup positions, right? Is Everett a TE or Receiver? Maybe we only keep 4 wrs? Only 7 linemen. 5 RB/FB. 5 TE's. Too soon to tell until I see them in pads. Especially the line.I would like to see how you would break down the "O" Player's!! How many O-Lineman - RB's - TE's etc.!?
That's what we all want Mack....that's why I come here everyday to see what people think.I just want whoever is there to run really good routes and catch the damn ball.
Those number for offensive player's look doable! I Have it this way:Cooper is a returner....KO returner to be exact...and can do the punt returns. ST's is important to Bones....I can see him, just due to his return skills, making the 53. He's also gonna be an improved wr. Thomas is like this to me also. And he's an even BETTER wr. Spruuuuce is spoken of as a better wr than these others...Not proven, but a lot of people think this. These 3 players are the tough, people always doubt type...And I really expect improvement in their 2nd years. Kupp, Reynolds, Woods, and....Austin are locks most think. Only Austin will play ST. Call me crazy....but after Woods, I want those 2nd year guys out there first. Kupp, Reynolds and Austin have to prove/show me they are ready.
Everett is a TE...while he will be used as a receiver....if we put him in the mix...we might only keep 4 wr....Wouldn't that put a dent in things????
I can't say for sure Dave...but imagine if Jamon Brown can play backup center, backup guard, and backup RT? That eliminates a bunch of players for backup positions, right? Is Everett a TE or Receiver? Maybe we only keep 4 wrs? Only 7 linemen. 5 RB/FB. 5 TE's. Too soon to tell until I see them in pads. Especially the line.
That's what we all want Mack....that's why I come here everyday to see what people think.
What about TE? Or are you adding them in with WRs?Those number for offensive player's look doable! I Have it this way:
* QB's = 3
* O-Line = 8
* WR's = 7
* RB's/FB = 4
That equals 22 on Offense and leaves 31 spots to fill-out the "D" and ST. ( Kicker-Punter-Kick return man-Punt return man-LS) That seems to work well!
Oops!! I forgot, 4 TE's! that brings the Offensive Player total to 26! that's perfect to me! ( Thanks I fixed it!!)What about TE? Or are you adding them in with WRs?
Oops!! I forgot, 4 TE's! that brings the Offensive Player total to 26! that's perfect to me! ( Thanks I fixed it!!)
Looks to me that the Saints carried 5 to 6 WRs on the roster last season and both the Falcons and the Redskins kept 6 on the roster.
Saints - Michael Thomas, Brandin Cooks, Brandon Coleman, Willie Snead, Tommylee Lewis, Jake Lampman.
Falcons - Julio Jones, Mohamed Sanu, Justin Hardy, Taylor Gabriel, Eric Weems, Aldrick Robinson
Redskins - Pierre Garcon, DeSean Jackson, Jamison Crowder, Ryan Grant, Josh Doctson, Rashad Ross
Well, from my perspective, I see a WR that can run solid routes and when the ball is thrown his way he catches the ball. I see that at as a valuable skillset for a WR. But that's me.I'm still not sure why Spruce is hyped SO much here. He had one okay preseason game against non-starters, got hurt and has not done crap since. IF he makes the squad, he'll be riding the pine most of time.
Well, from my perspective, I see a WR that can run solid routes and when the ball is thrown his way he catches the ball. I see that at as a valuable skillset for a WR. But that's me.
FWIW, I haven't been hyping anybody BTW. I went to the game in which Spruce got to play and play he did. It's not his fault when he got to play and at what level competition. The thing is he stood out against the level he was chosen to face. We'll just have to wait and see how he does against better competition if given the opportunity.
Yeah, he's a legit football player. If he doesn't make the Rams roster he will make some other team's roster and will likely do quite well for them. I'd bet Bellicheat would take him...I'll add a couple of other things that I observed in his limited playing time with the Rams. He is fearless over the middle. No alligator arms, he just catches the ball first and foremost, no cowering or hearing steps. He also is extremely intelligent with a good football IQ - very coachable. Additionally, Spruce will do everything possible to sell his routes even when he knows someone else's number has been called. He can and will block too.
I've gotten the impression that McVay is an extremely bright guy, I think it is safe to say football intelligence/IQ is very important to Sean. I will be astonished if a healthy Spruce doesn't make the final 53.
.